Hey!
This is a Power Review! 
Please remember that these are just my thoughts and somebody else might see it differently!
Initial hook: I've had this saved in my favourites list for a while because I wanted to come and read it and I finally got around to it last night while I was at work!
Storyline: This is a really creepy storyline! An old man appears to the band, The Plague, offering them a once in a lieftime opportunity. The band are unable to resist and after reading through the contract they all sign their lives away. They are transported to The club where it is fated for them to live out the rest of their lives.
The ending felt a little anti-climatic to me. Although it was good the way you did it and I liked it, I think because it all happens within a few paragraphs it went by a little too quickly for my liking. I wanted to feel the girls' pain when they were turned to dust, their lives gone. I wante to feel the panic rise, I wanted to see how shocked the band members were. So although it was a good ending I thought a little more description could really add to it.
Characters: Gramps: from the beginnign we know that something is not quite right with this old man. He's out of his depth and in the wrong context; we don't expect to see him where he is because stereotypically, he would not be there. I think that does well to jar the reader. You describe him well and especially towards the end of the story you allude to the fact that he is the Devil with the password on his accound and the fact that you called him the 'goat'. It works well and I think he made a really great character! He was an old man but much stronger than he looked, both physically and mentally.
Johnny: strikes me as the typical self-absorbed, thinks he's better than everyone type of guy adn that it's probably because he is in a band that made it relatively big. He treats the twins in the bus who are nibbling on his ear with bored distaste and I really disliked that. I found him to be quite an unlikeable character because of his attitude; he was too cocky for my liking. So you did well to characterise him and make me not like him!
Setting: The setting of this piece was the tour bus where the band seem to spend a lot of their time (as bands do). You describe it well throughotu and allow the reader ot understand the place and context of the story.
Atmosphere/tone: Clearly there is something not quite right throughout this piece. As a reader I knew it had to do with the old man who was very out of place, but I couldn't put my finger on why. So well done for keeping the reader intrigued in that way!
 A few suggestions I had:
Original quotes will be in black, any changes or suggestions I'll make in blue to make it clear 
"Did you see that old black guy, sittin' by himself in the center of the front row?
"Did you see that old black guy, sittin' by himself in the center of the front row?"
"When we reach that age we probably won't even have hair. We'll all look like Keith.
"When we reach that age we probably won't even have hair. We'll all look like Keith."
"All right then, Gramps, this is Bonsai, Keith, and you met Paul outside. The ladies are... what are your names again, girls?
"All right then, Gramps, this is Bonsai, Keith, and you met Paul outside. The ladies are... what are your names again, girls?"
"Lynard Skynard. Not the reincarnation. I mean the original lineup before the plan crash.
"Lynard Skynard. Not the reincarnation. I mean the original lineup before the plan crash."
Our manager, Johnny replied, "He's in L.A.,
"Our manager," Johnny replied, "He's in L.A.,
Hope this helped!
Well done on a good write!!
Reviewed on behalf of the WDC Power Reviewers Group:
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
|
|