Review Requests: ON
99 Public Reviews Given
104 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
<   1  2   >
1
1
In affiliation with Earl-Contests & Awards  
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is my personal view or take on your piece. You may accept or modify whatever suggestions I pointed out.
Thank you for joining "Echoes of The Heart Poetry Contest

Overall Impression:

This piece is clever, biting, and confidently sarcastic. The mock-eulogy format works very well, and the voice feels controlled and intentional. Your strength here is clearly in extended metaphor and comedic critique. The poem reads like a dark roast of failed humor.

The language is rich and playful, especially in the lists of descriptive words and comedy terminology. The tone stays consistent throughout, which is impressive for a longer free-verse piece. That said, a few sentences run long and could be tightened for stronger punch. Because this is humor about failed humor, rhythm and timing become especially important. Trimming in a few spots would sharpen the blade even more.

Overall, this is witty, stylized, and thematically cohesive.

Stanza I Like Most:

This passage is the strongest:

He’d launch a joke with the enthusiasm of a sloth on a treadmill,
The punchline landed with the subtlety of a brick through a stained-glass window.

Why it works:

*Checkg* The similes are vivid and funny.

*Heart* The escalation from slow energy → violent landing is effective.

*Checkg* The imagery is concrete and memorable.

*Heart* The comedic timing here is very strong.

*Checkg* This is where the satire feels most alive.


Verses or Lines That Need Improvement:

1. Sentence length could be tightened

Example:

Words that evoke lifelessness, pallid, inert, moribund, sterile, ashen, and wilted.

The list is effective but slightly heavy in one breath.

Consider breaking or slightly trimming to improve punch and readability.

Why: Comedy benefits from airflow and timing.

2. Slight clarity/flow issue

Each time Larry tried to be witty, it recorded the precise moment of death.

The subject of “it” is slightly unclear.

You may want to specify what is doing the recording (the room, the silence, the audience, etc.).

3. Minor overextension

The eyes that glazed over like a sitcom audience who just discovered the script was missing…

Funny idea, but the sentence runs long and loses some snap.

Consider tightening for sharper comedic timing.

Rhyming Scheme Review:

Form: Free verse / prose-poetry (eulogy style)

There is no fixed end-rhyme scheme, which fits the mock-eulogy tone well.

Instead, the piece relies on:

internal sound play

repetition

parallel phrasing

comedic rhythm

What works well:

The lack of rhyme supports the dry, deadpan delivery.

Your repetition of death/comedy vocabulary creates cohesion.

The return of the opening line at the end gives strong structural closure.

Optional enhancement (only if desired):
You could occasionally add light internal rhyme or sound echo for extra musicality, for example:

dead / dread

joke / choke

laugh / half

*Asteriskv* Not required, the current prose-eulogy style already works.

Write On

You clearly have strong control of voice and satirical tone. Your metaphors are imaginative, and the dark humor lands well. With some light tightening for timing and clarity, this piece could become even sharper and more performance-ready.

You’re doing smart, confident work here. Keep going.
A placeholder for the poetry contest.
2
2
In affiliation with Earl-Contests & Awards  
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is my personal view or take on your piece. You may accept or modify whatever suggestions I pointed out.
Overall Impression:

This poem feels light, musical, and very romantic. It has a soft fairy-tale quality, and the nature imagery creates a peaceful garden atmosphere. The repeated rhyme patterns give the poem a song-like flow, which fits well with the theme of music and harmony.

Your use of sound words (rhapsody, symphony, ballet, harmony) helps unify the poem nicely. However, some phrasing feels slightly repetitive, and a few lines could be made more natural in spoken rhythm. With small tightening and a touch more fresh imagery, the poem could feel even more vivid and memorable.

Stanza I Like Most:

Stanza 1 is the most charming:

Two lovers stroll through garden gate
and hear a rhapsody
as petals sway
and birds sashay
to lovers' rhapsody.

Why it works:

It clearly sets the romantic scene.

“birds sashay” is playful and musical.

The mood is immediately soft and dreamy.

It draws the reader gently into the poem.

Verses or Lines That Need Improvement:

1. Slight grammar smoothness:

Two lovers stroll through garden gate

Consider adding “the” (“through the garden gate”) for smoother flow.

Unless the omission is intentional for meter.

2. Repetition may feel heavy:
Examples:

to lovers' rhapsody

when hidden crickets play

the lilac's vibrant scent

to swing the lovers' fate

The repetition creates musicality (which is good), but in some places it feels a bit predictable. You might vary one or two repeated phrases to keep freshness.

3. Natural phrasing check:

with chickadee
in harmony

Grammatically fine, but slightly stiff in flow.

You might experiment with word order to sound more natural and lyrical.


Rhyme Scheme

Your poem follows a very consistent pattern.

Stanza Pattern:

Lines:

gate

rhapsody

sway

sashay

rhapsody

Rhyme scheme:
A B C C B

You maintain this exact structure in every stanza:

gate / fate / meant → A

rhapsody / play / scent / fate (B lines repeat within stanza)

sway / sashay, play / play, navigate / celebrate, harmony / fate → C C internal pair

Strengths:

*Checkg* Very disciplined and consistent

*Checkg* Musical and song-like

*Checkg* Refrain-style repetition is intentional and clear

Watch for:

Heavy predictability due to repeated B-line echoes

Some readers may feel the pattern is a bit too symmetrical

Write On

You have a lovely sense of musical structure and romantic imagery. The poem feels cohesive and gentle, like a nature waltz. With a bit more variation in repeated phrases and some small smoothing of lines, this piece could become even more graceful and memorable.

Keep writing. You have a beautiful lyrical instinct.
A placeholder for the poetry contest.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
3
3
Review of My... Sweetheart  
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thank you for posting an entry for
** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

First Impression
I don't know if I'm going to laugh or wanna cry about this piece. Maybe because in one moment of my life I experienced the same.
Written in a free verse, I like how you convey your message. It's easy to follow and I believe readers can relate to it. The first line suggests how painful the feeling is but as you read the next lines and verses one can see a determined and strong person behind the tears.

What I liked most
Verse 3 is my favorite. It shows that love knows no age and circumstances.

My suggestions
There is a slight of gray here. The last line is not really fit with that verse.
Maybe you can rename a place where it is known by everyone. How about going
to a garden, to a moonlight walk. A place that is something romantic.

To compromise with rings et al, -->> This line too needs revising. It's too legal term for this lovely piece.
How about saying ...with rings and vows...

Final Impression
You remind me of my early years. This piece can reach for more heights, I mean to say that it has a potential.
If you can employ or use some strong adjectives to it, then this piece deserves high rating.

Write on as always!
Earl



*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
4
4
Review of My Protector  
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **
Thank you for posting an entry.

Impression:
This is a cool tribute to a mother. I feel the thoughts are deeply attached to a mother. Strong words are chosen to convey the message. The idea of a mother's death is there but i would like to read it in a simple and easy way.

What I like?
These two lines caught my attention most.
Pain is harsh,
anguish stronger

It's very true but there's hope and comfort even on this moment of death.

My Suggestions:
the first line is a bit awkward...
"Note: View this Note" An unwilled cry escaped my lips.
Linked 'Note' not available. Try this line: tears of sadness escaped...

Write on!
Earl Pablo


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
5
5
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **
Thank you for posting an entry.

Impression:
I am curious why you titled it Unromantic Valentine. Well the message is clear and vivid. I regard the piece as an honest confession of how a guy would treat a sweetheart. Kind of feelings that woman don't really expect from a guy.

What I like?
Verse three (3). I can relate that. But hey I'm practicing to sing now.
The couplet is awesome.

My Suggestions:
No major suggestions for this piece.

Write on!
Earl Pablo


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
6
6
Review of New Season  
In affiliation with 30-Day Bloggers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
A very short piece about love
and you express it well through
few lines. This is a well-written
piece. I like the simplicity of it.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The last line caught my attention.
It summarized what the whole thing
was written for. Well done for that.

SUGGESTION
If you're a reader of this piece
would you ask for more thoughts
or verses? This is the same question
I would ask.

REMARKS
A splendid piece worth reading.
This verse feels me at peace.
Thanks for that.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

7
7
Review of The Poet  
In affiliation with 30-Day Bloggers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
A good rendition of how a poet works
or exploring a poet's world.
I agree that reading other poem
inspires us too.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
I like this line here:
he poet lives in mystery, churns mystery
Perfectly describes a poet.

SUGGESTION
It's just a piece of thought from me, how
about trimming down some lengthy lines?
Although this is written in a free verse
somewhat the flow and rhythm of the
piece is affected.

REMARKS
An interesting piece about a poet.
Nicely written and a good piece.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

8
8
Review of Another Birthday  
Rated: E | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
A neatly-written piece of a man's birthday.
The rhyming is impressive and the message
is vivid. Imagery is great.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The second verse. although it enumerates
the medications he took the resulting
end is interesting.

SUGGESTION
No major mistakes spotted but you may
double check this out:

I lie here in on this bed for days on end,

You could rephrase it like this:

I lie here in this room counting my days to end

REMARKS
I enjoy reading this piece. This reminds me of my
mom.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

9
9
Review of Where are You?  
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

When one reads this poem
he would then answer the questions.
Well-written poem. The rhyming
is very satisfactory. The imagery
is great. Readers could relate
well. No slung words used.

I could see the hunger for presence and love
here. This piece comes with strong
emotions.


Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

10
10
Review of From Beyond  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1787703 Unavailable **


Hi Snow!
I love reading this piece.
Words are expressed freely and with
no constraints.

Readers could depict a picture
clearly upon reading it.

No typos spotted.

This is a complementary review.
Thank you for joining "30-Day Blogging Challenge ON HIATUS

Earl
11
11
Review of Jesus  
In affiliation with  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
This is an impressive lyrical poem about Jesus.
I admire its simplicity and message.
Great piece to share and read to.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The flow is great. Each verse links/compliments
to each other.
The second to the last stanza is my favorite.

SUGGESTION
No major mistakes seen throughout the piece.

REMARKS
This is a wonderful piece.
A great tribute about one's hopes and
prayer.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

12
12
Review of Come Back, Baby!  
In affiliation with  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
What a beautiful piece.
Full of hope and inspiration. It makes one's
life merrier when reading it.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The rhythm is good, no hard bumps spotted
and the message runs smoothly.
it is easy to follow.

SUGGESTION
Choosing the word "hiatus" in the 15th line
seems awkward, but it can be reword into something
more deeper.

REMARKS
You make me inspired with this.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

13
13
Review of Crayola  
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
This is a creative work here.
The message flows easily with no much barriers.
Each verse compliments making this piece a must read.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
Third verse is my favorite.
Although there are no strong emotions
the simplicity of it is remarkable.

SUGGESTION
No major mistakes spotted along the way of my reading.


REMARKS
Thank you for sharing this and I have
a great reading.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

14
14
Review of the dance  
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
Reading this piece reminds me of a movie "Shall We Dance?"
starred by Richard Gere and Jennifer Lopez. Your last two verses
recalls also of another movie - "Save The Last Dance" and I'm
excited to read your piece.

I could feel a slight bump in your first two opening lines:

my heart’s music sends me
whirling around this friend

There's a need to revise your first line like-

a music fills the air
surrounds my friend


WHAT I LIKED MOST
The last line tells about courage and I like that.

SUGGESTION
I am not a great teacher but these lines
need reconstruction:

is my dance my own
or have I been guided always

I am confused of what you're trying to say with those
thoughts.

REMARKS
This piece will reap more reviews
if you do some repairs of it.
Try to read aloud and in many times
that way you can feel and hear what
lines should be shorter or longer
or what words and phrases to use.

You have a great potential as a poet,
just master the reading process
and try to maximize references.

Write on!
Earl: Poetry Contest Is On! Author IconMail Icon *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -

http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html

ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

15
15
Review of Walk with God  
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
This is a thought-pondering poem about one's supplication,
about humbling down, and submission.
First reading alone, a reader can really relate well
to the subject. Message is written in a smooth manner.
Sounds like a child's plea.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The last two lines are my pick.
It tells that God never leaves us.

SUGGESTION
No major mistakes or suggestions
to point out.

REMARKS
Well-written piece and I enjoy
reading it.
Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
ASIN: 1463660405
Product Type: Book
Amazon's Price: Price N/A

16
16
Review of The Silken Strand  
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
I see an interesting work here.
Written in a free verse format.
Some lines are too long
and thus affecting the rhythm.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The first four lines are my favorite.
They are simply conveyed and has
vivid meaning.

SUGGESTION
Try to shorten some long lines
in your piece. By so doing your pace
and rhythm will be amazing.

REMARKS
You make me smile with this piece.
Love reading it.

Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
http://lulu.com/product/ebook/echoes-from-the-hear...
17
17
Review of Silent Valentine  
Rated: E | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
It's a busy day for me after work. *Sad*
When I read your work, I feel at ease
with the sweetness *Heart* and simpleness
of the words used. This piece makes your
reader appreciates the beauty of the verses
you employed.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
Verse two especially the fifth and sixth lines.
I see life and pain here. Good combination
of thought.

SUGGESTION
No major mistakes to bring out.

REMARKS
This is a romantic piece for lovers
and for not just on Valentines Day.
I enjoy reading this.

Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
http://lulu.com/product/ebook/echoes-from-the-hear...
18
18
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi This is Earl giving you 3/3 poetry reviews from your auction wins
The Steam Powered Auction - CLOSED  (E)
An auction to benefit three great groups on WDC! Now closed!


You did well on this type of poetry.
You got an interesting title
Fonts and size are neat
No typos spotted
7th line catches my heart instantly
A very good question in the last line.
I love this piece.

Write on!
Earl

"The Power Reviewers HUB
19
19
Review of I Notice  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi This is Earl giving you 2/3 poetry reviews from your auction wins
The Steam Powered Auction - CLOSED  (E)
An auction to benefit three great groups on WDC! Now closed!


This is a lovely poem written to a wife.
She must be proud of it.
The font color and center-aligning are
simply impressive.
Words used are easy to follow.
Many lovers or husbands like me
can relate to this message.

Lines 7 to 10 are my favorites.
Great piece and I enjoy reading it.

Write on!
Earl

"The Power Reviewers HUB
20
20
Review of Family Memories  
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi This is Earl giving you 1/3 poetry reviews from your auction wins
The Steam Powered Auction - CLOSED  (E)
An auction to benefit three great groups on WDC! Now closed!


I love this poetry style so much.
You penned a wonderful message here.
Although to some this type of poetry is
not appealing and yet you managed to
convey the message concisely.

i see no major mistakes to point out.
Do you have in the future add another verse
or two?

Write on!
Earl

"The Power Reviewers HUB
21
21
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
This is a very expressive piece of pain and agony
of a divorced life.
Each line compliments with each other giving
a smooth flow.
If this is a fictitious or not piece, I admire its
contents.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
Words used are easy to read.
Verse three is my favorite.
The anguish and mood of questioning is interesting to note.

SUGGESTION
Verse seven can be deleted or rewritten.
the thought therein are the same in last two
verses. This is an option though.

REMARKS
Nicely written and I enjoy reading it.

Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
http://lulu.com/product/ebook/echoes-from-the-hear...
22
22
Rated: E | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
This piece comes with a interesting adjectives to hide
the meanings of its lines. The message isn't implied
and is left to the readers of their interpretation.
There is a progression from the start to the nice
concluding lines.
the poem paints a city well.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
I liked how it is structured.
These three lines catch my attention:

Raindrops still fall on my city,
Safeguarding dusty highways,
Dirty streets filled with an ethereal beauty,

SUGGESTION
There's one you left out -

The rain says welcome home,
That['s] why it rains so much,

REMARKS
Well-written free form poetry.

Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
http://lulu.com/product/ebook/echoes-from-the-hear...
23
23
Review of No more Mammals  
Rated: E | (4.0)
THANK YOU *BIGSMILE* for posting an entry at

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

FIRST IMPRESSION
The piece is very short. I consider this as a free-hand poem.
The writer sets no rule in the technicalities (I guess).
Message employed is interesting though it can be written
in a simple one liner poem or sentence.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
The feeling rendered is straight forward.
No mixed emotions.
I liked the last two lines.

SUGGESTION
Do you consider putting some verses?
In so doing, the piece will reap more reviews
and contents will be flowing.

REMARKS
A simple poem for lovers.

Write on!
Earl *Heart*
See my first published book/e-book -
http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html
http://www.amazon.com/Echoes-From-The-Heart-ebook/...
24
24
Review of American Marines  
Rated: E | (4.5)
THANK YOU *Smile* for posting an entry for

** Image ID #1626865 Unavailable **

IMPRESSION
*Idea* This is a great tribute poem to the soldiers not only in the USA but also in the whole soldier world. The piece runs smoothly with its couplet in center-aligned. The couplet titles are amazing, giving your readers a glimpse of ideas and thoughts. Words used are not coerced.

WHAT I LIKED MOST
*Idea* The "Team" couplet strikes me very hard. *Bigsmile*
It has truth and sincerity when it is written.

SUGGESTION
*Idea* I think US of A to rhyme with pay isn't working out well. Try to reword it like: USA and so we say. Something like that. You have option anyway to take it or not.

REMARKS
*Idea* A very good piece worth reading for.
Reading it helps me to be more patriotic. *Smile*

Write on! *Smile*
Earl
Published author at last - http://i-proclaimbookstore.com/ecfrhe.html



25
25
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1787703 Unavailable **

Thank you for registering to this challenge which will
start on July 1, 2011. This is a complimentary review.

The blog header is colorful. It gives your reader
an excitement to read on.
You have written longer entries in each page and that
tells me you have really something to share.


I couldn't wait to read your blogs soon.

Write on!
Earl

35 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 2 25 per page   < >