Review Requests: ON
165 Public Reviews Given
202 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
My goal is to give a detailed, organized review that highlights the positive characteristics of the work, while also touching on any areas that might benefit from some editing. All of my reviews are, of course, just suggestions and meant to be helpful to the author. I am always available via WDC email if more input is needed on any aspect of the review.
I'm good at...
I excel at analyzing spelling, grammar, punctuation, timeline continuity, and the flow of the story. I prefer to review fiction but can apply my knowledge to non-fiction as well. My knowledge of the fundamentals of poetry is very limited (at the moment at least!). My reviews of poems tend to be more along the lines of how it comes across to me, how it made me feel, and what I visualized when reading it.
Favorite Genres
Fiction, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, Romance, Mystery, Comedy, Inspirational, Family, Military, Holidays
Least Favorite Genres
Non-Fiction, Horror
Favorite Item Types
Short stories, books, contest entries, blogs
I will not review...
Erotica
Public Reviews
<   1  2  3  4   >
1
1
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Shirley Author Icon, this is a review of "The Flavour of Ghosts.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: An article discussing paranormal and the coinciding flavors that come with the incidents. It uses both narrative and dialogue, which is an interesting combination for the subject and experiences shared. Detailed and descriptive, it brings the reader into the environment where the paranormal was experienced. Even if the reader doesn’t necessarily believe in ghosts, they could be resoundingly convinced that the author has enough evidence to support their personal claim.

*Checkg* Detailed narrative. My desk sits in the corner where I have everything behind me. I could picture speaking to someone as you were on Skype and having a similar thing happen to me here. It will definitely make me more aware of my surroundings, especially when it’s late.

*Checkg* Supporting dialogue. I enjoyed the dialogue in this biographical article. It was a nice change to only getting narrative (which can be dry at times, though yours was not at all). I could feel the confusion between both of you and that doubt that sits in the backs of our minds when things like this happen.

*Checkg* Descriptions of flavors. One, I had never thought to try and notice these possible changes when something possibly paranormal happened. I will be keeping them in mind going forward. The way you described the flavors immediately put me in mind of the possible ghost – what kind of person were they, what happened to them to associate with that flavor, could it be that they get to choose what flavor comes to mind for the living, and is it different for each person?

*Checkg* Connections. I loved your mention of your son and of your own childhood. Those memories create a flow beyond the immediate timeframe of the occurrences you are relating to the reader. I felt those details wrapped around the story to make it whole.

*Starg* No typos either grammatical or punctual. My only comment would be on the length of the second paragraph. I understand why it is all together and can’t argue the fact that it creates that anxious flow of what is happening. From a reading standpoint, I did almost get lost a time or two because of the length. Not sure that I even suggest breaking it up, just giving some feedback.

Lasting Impressions: I loved the article. I’ve had some of my own experiences in different houses. The house I grew up in was the one my dad was born in, so rather aged and had only been in our family. I used to hear my name said quietly or whispered when only I was there. In other instances, there have been flashing/flickering lights at very specific times/events in my life. As I said earlier, I had never thought to pay attention to what I was tasting. I will definitely will be on my mind in the future.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
2
2
Review of Lost  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi cheshire Author Icon, this is a review of "Lost.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A creative work that evokes visceral imagery regarding a single soul among the infinite. Each stanza takes the reader through a different relation of what that soul might feel like out among everything else. The chosen imagery has the opportunity to evoke feelings of isolation, loneliness, danger and endurance. The work begins with desolation but ends with a feeling of inspiration.

*Checkg* Powerful imagery. The descriptions given in each stanza transport the reader to that place and time and what the soul is facing there. These words struck me the most: torrents, relentlessly, smashes, endless, and courage.

*Checkg* Interesting progression. The start is desolate and the finish is inspirational, but the journey there is propelled forward by contemplative descriptions of the soul itself.

A soul (lost to time)
Aimless soul (disappearing)
Fragment of a soul (following its brothers)
Frightened soul (endless sea of people)
Enduring soul (lost in the world around it)

Though this soul has been lost, battered and bruised, challenged and scared, it still has the courage to stand its ground and exist amidst the world. Perhaps no longer lost to time but still lost among the many.

*Checkg* Motion. There is a lot of movement in this poem that helps the reader feel as though they are there with the soul as it faces the challenges. The set that impacted me the most were in the second stanza: floats, forces, drifts.

*Starg* Typo. The markup language is visible in the last line where you wanted the word ‘not’ to be italicized.

Lasting Impressions: I was surprised at the end when I felt that inspiration. From the title and the beginning of the poem, I expected to still feel adrift at the conclusion. It was a pleasant discovery to see that even among the trials the soul had to face, it still held strong. It still might not feel connected to everything around it, but it knows who it is and for now, that’s enough.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
3
3
Review of Tickled Pink  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello PENsive is Meemaw x 3! Author Icon, this is a review of "Tickled Pink.

Happy WDC anniversary! 21 wonderful years of sharing your creativity! Thank you for sharing it with us.
*Delight*

I loved the story of the night you became a grandmother. I felt like I was there riding along with you in the car racing to get back to the hospital. I wouldn't have been able to sleep either! It does seem like stress, even good stress, can bring out the bickering in couples. My parents were definitely like this and I know my husband and I do the same.
I anticipated the same from Walter's actions and I am so glad that it went the other way! The joy at getting to hold her for the first time comes through in your words. My favorite detail of all the things you get to do with your granddaughter is her 'reading' to you. Our kids did that for us and I loved their versions of the stories better! How imaginative little ones can be! They are such a blessing to have.

I wish you many more happy years here at WDC!

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

Celebrating you with an Anniversary Review.
4
4
Review of Tom  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Sumojo Author Icon, this is a review of "Tom.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: I love a good short story that leaves me with more questions than the ones I found reading it. Short stories are a little glimpse into something bigger and with this one we learn of an old tomcat named Tom that may be more than he seems. It starts with the sad occurrence of June having to say a final goodbye to her grandmother. It ends with us looking at Tom wondering just what else he might be in addition to a cat.

*Checkg* Good hook. The beginning draws readers in with the quiet tragedy that just occurred in June’s life, as well as the last words her grandmother had for her.

*Checkg* Interesting details. Sprinkled throughout the story are details about Tom that raise our suspicion. He’s been there for as long as June can remember. He isn’t nice to June but behaves well for the neighbor. Though he is skin and bones, he's still spry. At the end, he has his paw on the planchette.

*Checkg* Relatable characters. We don’t have much time with these characters, but their circumstances are relatable. Losing a loved one. Going through their things after they have departed. Asking someone to care for your pet after you are gone. Speaking with the family after your friend has passed.

*Starg* No typos. Only one suggestion.

“next visited Granny’s house to start emptying the house” – the word house is used twice close together

Using the same word close together can pull the reader out of the scene. Sometimes the phrase can be reworded, or another word could be used. It’s really only personal preference.

Lasting Impressions: Tom’s story will stay with me, especially around Halloween. The story was the kind I like best. It had an underlying mystery that left me curious after I finished it, but it wasn’t anything really frightening. If you ever expand upon Tom’s story, I would love to see what happens.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
5
5
Review of Frank's Halloween  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi Jacky Author Icon, this is a review of "Frank's Halloween.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A cute Halloween story about the last piece of candy and the last trick or treater. Poor Frank! He tries his best to get that candy, but still no luck at the end. At least he makes good by heading to the store to replace the can of green beans!

*Checkg* Misdirection. I honestly thought the little dragon was either a statue or a real dragon at the beginning of this. *Smile* In hindsight, I think it was because the color was silver. For a children’s costume, I expected a shade of green. I really liked this twist.

*Checkg* Likable character with flaws. Frank ended up being a character that I liked. I did cheer the little dragon for grabbing both items and being excited about the green beans. I also cheered Frank for going to the store.

*Checkg* Surprise ending. The fact that the store was closed at the end gave the audience an additional laugh.

*Starg* Typos. Only a couple that I found.

squeaked out “Trick or Treat!” – needs a comma after the word out

Green beans too!!” – needs quotation marks before the word Green

Lasting Impressions: I really enjoyed the short story. The topic was relatable, it had a memorable main character and storyline, a couple of added twists, and a lesson. Sounds like Frank will have learned his lesson and hopefully Alice isn’t to hard on him the next day. After all, he did get outwitted by a little silver dragon. *Wink*

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
6
6
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Emberly Gray Author Icon, this is a review of "Am I the only one? .

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A poem that breaks open the silence of an aching heart wondering if they are the only one grieving the loss of the relationship. It is free form with no rhyming sequence but does not need one. The rhythm established by the placement of the words within the lines is impactful.

*Checkg* Varied font size. The first line being larger than the rest gave me the impression that it was said in full voice, while the rest is spoken in a whisper. It brought to mind the first real relationship as a young adult. The one where the grief of losing that person in your life in that role is so very different than the puppy love type of relationships you had experienced as a child. Yet, in some ways, you still feel like a child when heartbreak comes.

*Checkg* Chosen ending/beginning words for each line. Many of the lines held more emphasis for me because of the placement of the first/last word for the sentence.

Example:

arguing with memories,
trying to make them make sense?

Do you ever miss me
the way I miss you?

*Checkg* Evocative words. The words paint a picture of the broken heart that is wrestling with coming to terms that the love that was once returned is no longer there. Perhaps their own depth of love was not equal on the other side and that is what is echoed in the silence.

I found no mistakes with the poem. I do have one possible consideration to mention.

For these lines:

holding pieces
you already let go of?

This wording came to me:

holding the pieces
you already let go?

As always – not a suggestion to change it. I think it works perfectly as it is.
I think the only reason that popped into my head was how well the use of the last words caught my attention. The word ‘of’ as the last line of the last sentence sort of made my mind reword it automatically.

Lasting Impressions: I am a hopeless romantic. As such, I love good romance, but I also relate to the depth of emotion from a heartbreak. Love and loss. Two sides of the same coin. That feels like it is well illustrated in this piece of work.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
7
7
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hi Liz B Author Icon, this is a review of "The Cat Who Stayed.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A piece of prose that felt like I was sitting down with the person listening to them tell me everything. It is centered around them finding a cat and taking care of it, which is all the more important because they are allergic to cats. It has great humor, a little adventure, and sadness, but frames the sadness in a way that is all about coping and understanding themselves and life.

*Checkg* Continuous flow. From the beginning to the end, it was as though I was in the story experiencing the moments with the person.

*Checkg* Impressive first-person narrative. It is told from one perspective with very little dialogue, but that only enhances the tale. Again, it felt like a one-on-one conversation with the person telling it.

*Checkg* Good transitions. Smooth transitions that told of time passing and the events occurring.

*Checkg* Relatable moments:

*Bulletg* Taking care of the cat despite the allergy.
*Bulletg* Concern for her during the winter and when she couldn’t be found.
*Bulletg* Making a mistake with the catnip, feeling dismay and upset, then shame for what had happened.
*Bulletg* Interpreting the cat’s feelings about the dogs being allowed in, but not her.
*Bulletg* Sadness at the fact that she wasn’t coming back.

Favorite Line:
“I don’t recall the year Haraam joined us, but I remember when she left.”
The poignancy of this line tore at my heart, more so even than the line about her paw prints leading away. It speaks to how I think many of us look back on the end of things in our life and emphasizes the loss.

*Starg* Typo. Only found one typo. “so her rented one and hauled it” – maybe should be he instead of her?

Lasting Impressions: I am a cat person, so this one hit close to my heart. I came to love Haraam during the story and felt grief at her parting. However, the eloquent way the end is told did not leave me with my grief. Instead, it reinforced the knowledge that loving someone means one day letting them go. The gift of having known them was worth the hurt. Beautiful prose.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
8
8
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Loyd Gardner Author Icon, this is a review of "Here I am. Send me.--Chapter Ten.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: I found this piece to review by clicking the ‘Read and Review’ link on the left side menu. It’s always interesting when I do that because sometimes, like now, I get dropped into the middle of a story. In this case, I was given Chapter 10 of a novel.

The chapter is well written and a snapshot into the rest of the book. I didn’t feel lost reading only this part, instead it made me curious about the rest of the story. The chapter takes place after a school shooting. The main characters in it are a social worker and a pastor. Romance is hinted with the interest only being seen from one perspective. The tragedy that took place prior to this scene is mentioned, as well as a hint about the mystery involved.

*Checkg* Great character development. Seeing through Evelyn’s perspective, I got to know her fairly well just in this short time.

*Checkg* Supportive dialogue. The dialogue is descriptive and supports character development and the plot. I love learning the story through the characters and not just the narrative.

*Checkg* Smooth flow. From beginning to end of the chapter, everything felt in the right place.

*Checkg* Intriguing plot. The mystery of the shooting and the reason behind it captured my attention immediately.

It’s not often that I get to say that I didn’t find one mistake or anything to suggest improving, but this is definitely one of those times. I read through it carefully several times and still found nothing. Great job!

Lasting Impressions: I will be returning to see the earlier chapters of the novel and the later ones. Getting to drop into the story at chapter 10, it left me with a nearly complete idea of what was already happening and enough of a hook to wonder what the rest is like.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
9
9
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi John Author Icon, this is a review of "Which Prophecy Works.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: Two possible prophecies to be used as the prologue for a novel. Both are detailed and have aspects that appeal to the audience and hook the reader into the rest of the story.

Perhaps a combination of both prophecies, pulling from each to discover a third version that harnesses aspects of both works:
Prophecy I – Stanzas 1, 2, and 3
Prophecy II – Stanzas 4 and 5
Prophecy I – Stanza 6
Prophecies I and II (combination of lines) – Stanza 7: First 3 lines from Prophecy II, last line from Prophecy I
Prophecies I and II (combination of lines) – Stanza 8: First 2 lines from Prophecy II, last 2 lines from Prophecy I

The reasoning here is that the wording and flow of each of these and their combination feels smooth. It also retains all of the pertinent information.

Highlighted Items: These stood out to me. Not as good or bad, just stood out.
*Starg* Lost Heir and Assassin are capitalized, but the third person is not.
*Starg* The third person is a lesser noble’s son in Prophecy I and an instructor’s son in Prophecy II.
*Starg* The third person in Prophecy I gets their power from Wizard’s curse, but not in Prophecy II.

Lasting Impressions: It feels as though you are pretty solid on the hints and background for the Assassin and the Lost Heir, but maybe you are still thinking through the third person’s details and considering how their part in the story will begin. That’s a good place to be, in my opinion. Feel out that third character and see how their puzzle piece should be shaped to fit in with all the other pieces you’ve already found.

You have a great storyline here. Wishing you and your characters the best as their story unfolds.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
10
10
Review of DnD Creature Quiz  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi kadenkoker Author Icon, this is a review of "DnD Creature Quiz.

I loved your crossword puzzle! I am a big fan of DnD and this was a very fun item to come across!
*Clap*

*CheckG* Large number of terms.
*CheckG* Great subject!
*CheckG* Variety of word lengths.
*CheckG* Descriptive clues (thanks for the # of letters!).
*CheckG* Challenging!

There were three terms that were tricky for me. Each of them had multiple options that worked with the given letter length and the letters that were supplied by other terms. It took me three submissions to get it all right, which is pretty satisfying because I normally get things on the first try! I love one that challenges me.
*Smile* I did not look anything up, on my honor. *FingersCrossed* BUT, I did get my family to help! *Laugh* My husband helped a LOT. Our youngest got the last one for me that was causing me some problems!

I usually create crosswords that have to do with holidays or history. Your DnD crossword has given me the idea to break out of those zones and put some up related to DnD and maybe just games in general.

The white dragon image goes well with the subject.

I don't really have any improvement ideas to offer because this was so well done. I can offer this detail that I had not thought of doing with my crosswords before until I took part in an activity that suggested it. The activity required us to do a poem and provide subject appropriate images in the body of the description for the crossword. I hadn't thought of combining those aspects of creativity together, so it was a fun task to do.

Thanks for sharing your crossword with us!

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
11
11
Review of My Feelings  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Naomi Author Icon, this is a review of "My Feelings.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A beautiful essay that says so much in so few words. It was written as a personal essay, but by sharing it with everyone, we have the benefit of this wisdom, encouragement and enlightenment.

*Checkg* Tone. The tone felt peaceful, like a morning affirmation.

*Checkg* Pace. The flow was calm. The spacing of the lines helped reinforce the purpose.

*Starg* Typos. Only 2 that I could see:

“I have thoughts , but, I am more than my thoughts” – No space after ‘thoughts’ and needs a period at the end.

*Checkg* Positive outlook. Even when speaking of negative thoughts and feelings, the author keeps a positive view to address them. Acceptance that these are a part of life and emphasis on how we deal with the negative to get through to the positive.

Lasting Impressions: My favorite line is “Whatever they are, all my feelings are vital and essential in expressing the complete me.” An important part of being emotionally healthy is being able to acknowledge and express bad feelings in a way that is safe for you and others. Ignoring the negative side of things or bottling it up can only make things worse.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
12
12
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi TheJessenovels Author Icon, this is a review of "Hostile Takeover Pt.1.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: The prologue drops the reader into a covert military mission backed by political intrigue. No one will know what has happened this night and the team executing the assignment is a cohesive unit that needs little expression between them to operate under demanding circumstances. Everything seems to be going as planned until it doesn’t.

*Checkg* and *Starg* Great technical details (a lot of them). In many ways, it is the details that writers give that make or break the story for the audience. After all, authors paint the picture inside their heads with words so everyone else can take part in the experience. I definitely felt as though I was seeing what was happening through your eyes. The scene came alive for me.

For me, there could have been less details about the transport and weaponry. I am familiar with the terms and while they do enhance the experience, there was an abundance of them in a very short space. I found myself skimming through some, which pulled me out of the scene and had me going back to check and make sure I didn’t miss anything pertinent in between the descriptions.

*Checkg* Appropriate tone. The way the team handled the mission and interacted with one another set the tone. Heart rate increased due to anticipation, not fear. (And a very appropriate word choice using ‘anticipation’, not something like ‘excitement’.)

*Checkg* Good character development. These characters meant something to me in a short amount of time.

*Checkg* Writing style. I enjoy writing styles that are short and to the point. This one follows that style in the narrative and the dialogue.

*Checkg* Good dialogue. The dialogue used enhances the story, is appropriate to the setting, and supports character development.

*Starg* Punctuation. Only two places that stood out to me for punctuation.

“No night vision. No coordination” – the period is there, but on the next line after ‘coordination’

“arterial spray painting the grass” – no punctuation here

Lasting Impressions: The prologue feels like the ‘tip of the iceberg’ for this novel. The key scene is a great hook to pull the reader forward into the story, leaving us wanting to know what happened and why. A larger review pool could help with feedback on the quantity of specific details in the beginning. Definitely an intense read that leaves the audience on the edge of their seat and waiting for the next installment.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*4leaf* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A dragon reading a book by candle light
13
13
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi OxTxFxGxK Author Icon, this is a review of "YUIMETAL: "The Fall".

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: An interesting non-fiction essay focusing on the evolution of a Japanese band called BABYMETAL. It is a detailed study of a specific accident, an injury and subsequent departure of one of the members of the band. The essay uses a mixture of facts, supported by linked images, video, and articles (some in Japanese), to contrast and compare fan speculation against officially released information.

*Checkg* Organized format. The essay is written with a consistent organized structure that makes it easier to read. The beginning provides a ‘Key People and Terms’ section that is a helpful reference. The sections and subsections are clearly marked. Adequate use of spacing and white space to guide the reader through the piece. Formatting for the band names, album titles, and songs appears to be correct and consistent.

*Checkg* and *Starg* Reference links. The essay is marked as research. It provides links to reference materials where many of the facts have been found. If this piece is written for submission for a grade or to a publication, then it would be beneficial (and maybe a requirement) to use citations throughout the essay and provide a reference list at the end. If it is only for personal use, citations would still be useful and appropriate.

*Checkg* Introduction and Conclusion. There is a lot of information in this essay. The introduction and conclusion do a good job of leading the reader into the piece and then providing a summary exit.

*Checkg* Appreciation of the topic. Reading through non-fiction can be a challenge. It is always helpful if the person writing the essay is invested in the topic and that comes through in the writing. I believe this was more than achieved during this piece.

*Starg* Embedded links. This refers back to having a list of citations/references at the end. Only relying on embedded links creates a risk. If there are any problems (broken links, varying software to open the links – browsers on computers vs. phone apps, links not properly embedded), then the reader loses access to pertinent information. It is best to have a backup list with the link listed out, so the reader can try an alternate method of accessing it if necessary.

Lasting Impressions: I do not normally review non-fiction, so this was an interesting work to explore. While I am very vaguely familiar with K-Pop (due to knowing someone who enjoyed it greatly in the past), I had never heard anything about J-Pop. It is interesting to see how different cultures handle musical groups and their work.

The use of “The Lore” to explain management decisions is an intriguing concept, though I also feel it should be a cautionary practice. While it may provide a mystical appeal to the fanbase and somewhat protect the privacy of the performers, it could also cause damage to some fans who don’t fully understand the concept and perhaps hide neglectful practices by management towards their clients.

I can definitely say that I would not have known all of this information if I had not read this essay. I felt the work encompassed the spirit of the writer and their feelings regarding the subject. It was easy to navigate and provided supporting references to reinforce the research aspect. More definition for the references would enhance the experience for the reader.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share

Image #2325341 over display limit. -?-
14
14
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi DS Author Icon, this is a review of "The Night To Haunt.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A contest entry for the Writer’s Cramp right before Halloween that tells a story and points out how an overprotective nature can stifle someone’s longing for adventure. Though I felt it met the criteria, it also skimmed along the edge of the allegorical requirement. It is filled with phrases that suggest what is happening and the cadence is appealing.

*Checkg* Met the ‘surface plot’ requirement of the contest. The image is clear to me of the youngster who was held back by the request of their guardian to not participate in Halloween celebrations. Both the longing of the one wanting to go and the concern of the one wanting them to stay came through clearly for me.

*Checkg* *Checkg* Wording. The third stanza was my favorite for using words/phrases to evoke images. Wonderful! *Smile*

‘Predators revelling in the grace they lack’

‘words wielded like a surgeon's knife’

‘forcing darkest shadows to bleed into light’

All of these reinforced the concern felt by the guardian and rang true for the season of Halloween.

*Starg* Grammar. Only one comment.

*Bulletg* The first word in the first line – ‘stood’ – has an odd feel for me when reading it, likely because it is past tense while the later verbs are present tense. I can understand why it was used and can’t disagree with the choice, but to read it aloud or in my head, it makes the beginning ‘hiccup’ for me.

*Starg* Contest entry prompt. In my opinion, it is an intriguing poem, but I couldn’t put my finger on the exact allegorical reference that was being made. What I got from the piece was overprotectiveness vs. yearning for adventure. While that is a part of the larger community (parenting to be specific – guilty of it myself), I’m not sure it pinpointed what the contest was requesting. I freely admit that I can sometimes miss concepts though, so please let me know if it was something else.

*Checkg* Cadence. I couldn’t detect a set or recurring cadence, but what was used felt right for the poem. The second stanza was my favorite for cadence. How it flowed and especially how it ended put me in the mind of when Winifred in Hocus Pocus is saying the spell to change the boy into a cat. Very appealing. *Smile*

Lasting Impressions: This brought a smile to my heart when I found it. Halloween is the beginning of the holiday season for me, and I anticipate it every year. We are beyond that particular part of the year for now but reading this reminded me that it won’t be so long before it has returned.

Being a parent, it drew forth the concerns I experienced for our children. I felt it did a wonderful job of illustrating the contrast between the feelings of the child vs. the guardian and did so in an entertaining and colorful way.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share

Image #2325341 over display limit. -?-
15
15
Review of Tee  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi Zeke Author Icon, this is a review of "Tee.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: ‘Pride goeth before a fall.’ The first chapter of this novel introduces the main character, Tee, and gives the reader a detailed look into his life and character in a fairly short amount of time. While there is plenty of reasons to dislike him, there is an underlying current of consideration that makes the reader at least curious as to how he got to this place in his life, if not evoking sympathy for him. The story is set up for different paths. Will he try to redeem himself? Will he punish himself for both his actions/inactions? It is the possibility of either an inspirational ending or a cautionary tale that makes the reader look forward to the next chapter.

*Checkg* Character development. Interactions and dialogue with his family, co-worker, and his environment detail what kind of man Tee is at this point in his life. His past is hinted at through narrative that lets us wonder if he wasn’t always this way. The vivid images of who he is pulls us into the story.

*Checkg* Tone. The overall tone was suspenseful, which was fitting. From the domestic problems at home, to the perilous and careless drive into work, then his callous treatment of his co-worker, the tension is on a slow burn and building.

*Starg* Accents. I’m in favor of using defining aspects of dialogue to help round out the character and set the tone for the reader. However, I do feel that it is a fine line to walk. The mention of it being specifically a Cajun accent was appropriate, in my opinion, to distinguish it from a purely southern accent. I do think that the phrase “ya’ll” was overused. It disrupted the flow for me, and I was pulled out of the scene. Instead of subtilty, it felt like a neon billboard proclaiming over and over again that he was Cajun.

It could be eliminated in some areas, which would ease the obviousness and enhance that Cajun drawl. Southerners do use it often, but they also use the word ‘you’. It shouldn’t be used to replace all instances of the word ‘you.’ I lived in Georgia for a while and am now in what is still considered the south.

For instance:
"You have a wonderful day too," he mutters to the empty kitchen. (only his daughter being addressed)
"Aw, Che'. Don't be like that." (eliminate it from here and it feels more natural)

*Starg* Grammatical/Punctuation Errors. Though there were these errors throughout the piece, they did not take away from the overall feel. The ones that were there felt as though they were done by accident and would be caught in future drafts.

Only one specific highlight that might not be caught by spell/grammar check:
When you use the words ‘humanely’ and ‘inhumanely’, I don’t think they are said correctly in context. Debbie corrects Tee, but in the text, he said what she said the first time.

*Checkg* Descriptive wording/phrases. You have a talent for using colorful phrases to paint images for the reader.

Sometimes they tell us things about the character without having to say it directly.
The coffee tastes bitter.

Other times, they create the scene with startling clarity.
The sound reverberates off the mansion's facade—pure power, barely contained.

*Checkg* Keeping it succinct. For some readers – of which I am one – reading is a joy but also can be time consuming. When I read, I tend to want the story to keep a decently fast pace. Cutting out unnecessary words is a blessing to me. It sets the tone, keeps me in the scene, and saves time.

*Checkg* and *Starg* Character arc. You build a terrific beginning to a rich character arc for Tee. The only consideration is how soon (and what it is) that creates the ultimate fall for him in the eyes of the reader. For me, it was him not opening the door for Debbie. On the surface, I understand that fear can override actions. On a personal level, this was a non-redeemable action for me for this character. Now, I am faced with deciding if I want to hear the rest of his story or close the book.

Lasting Impressions: Tee seems to be one of those characters that I might love to hate. I still may want to see what happens to him, but after his actions with Debbie, I’m not rooting for any good ending for him. For me, the best he could achieve is trying to make amends for his transgressions. (This goes for even if Debbie is fine outside those doors. His actions decided it for me.) Again, it is all tied to the overall meaning of the story – inspirational or cautionary tale. Both serve good purposes, but are possibly geared towards different audiences. Whichever this turns out to be, the writing style is rich with detail and takes the reader along for an action-packed ride.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
16
16
Review of Too Many Tiaras  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi Jeffrey Meyer Author Icon, this is a review of "Too Many Tiaras.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A tale that takes the reader through the dark side of the beauty pageant system and is told from the narrative point of view. The dialogue enhances the woman’s horrific circumstances. There are a few graphic depictions that hone in on the loss of innocence that comes with participating in these events.

*Checkg* Tone. Psychological horror can be far more frightening than physical threats. As the piece explores the broken mind of the woman, we are taken through the nightmarish existence where she lives. By the end, we see that most of it is twisted reality, which is even more distressing.

*Checkg* Shock Value. The blood pouring from between Miss Arizona’s legs. Her grandmother calling her a whore. The teacher that took nude pictures but had had better. The guy in the audience pleasuring himself. These points in the story elevate the tale from just frightening to terrifying. Imagined or real, these experiences would warp a young mind.

*Starg* Due to the graphic nature of some of the details, I would recommend consideration to change the age restriction on this piece 18+. Right now there are no access restrictions.

*Starg* Grammar. Only one tiny detail. “daughters useless vanity” needs to be “daughter’s useless vanity”. Otherwise, everything looked great.

*Checkg* Consistency. I appreciated the way the story began and ended. We are thrown into a haunting situation, which is actually seeing things from inside Linnette’s mind. By the end, we are seeing things from her perspective, but a different one. This single thin thread spoke to me that, in some form or fashion, she has the most tenuous hold on reality still. I am not left feeling good about that fact. It does evoke more empathy for her.

Lasting Impressions: What struck me the most about the tale was the subject of it and how it was portrayed. Here we have events that are centered around beauty when in reality there is an undercurrent of ugliness that pervades not just the contests, but the lives of those involved. Taking that a step further, I found myself examining the past and current times where looks are valued over substance. I’m definitely glad that I did not grow up in a family where these contests are revered.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
17
17
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi Duane Engelhardt Author Icon, this is a review of "When the Whistle Blew.

*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


Happy WDC Anniversary! Thank you for sharing your creativity with us. I hope this review finds you well and still contributing your unique take on storylines with your audience.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: Told from the perspective of a grandchild, we are never given more insight into the narrator other than that bit of knowledge. The focus of the short tale centers on the events of the grandmother’s experience as a young girl. A poignant reminder that for some the possibility of tragic events hangs in the balance each and every day due to their careers. Though perhaps in not the same circumstances, this is still true for those working in similar dangerous vocations. Though the grandmother’s family is not directly affected by the loss, it is her family that shoulders the responsibility of beginning the process to move beyond the tragedy.

*Checkg* Narration. I appreciated the tale being told by the unknown grandchild. I felt as though I was one of the younger generations listening to the story by the fireplace.

*Checkg* Perspective. A short coming of age tale for a young girl whose day begins with a much more youthful outlook and ends with the serious understanding of the important role her family plays for the community.

*Checkg* Tone. The overall tone of the piece felt somber, which was fitting.

*Starg* Very few grammatical issues or typos. None took away from the overall feeling of the piece.

“Sunday’s” should be “Sundays”

“We’ll need for seven men and three boys.” – this is either missing a word, could use different wording, or meant to be a speech pattern

A few sentences felt long and could have possibly been broken into shorter, more concise ones.

Lasting Impressions: The tale of this young girl coming to understand why she is called a ‘ghoul’ by the other kids will stay with me. For me, the part where someone shoved her aside as the priest entered felt like it was representative of her childhood being cast aside by this tragic event and realization of her family’s role when things like this happened.

Thank you for sharing your story with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

Celebrating you with an Anniversary Review.
18
18
Review of ODE TO NATURE  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Debbie M Author Icon, this is a review of "ODE TO NATURE.

*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


Happy WDC Anniversary! Thank you for sharing your thoughts and creativity with us. I hope this review finds you well and that you are still finding ways to express your love of nature and animals.

Overall: All of the expected criteria for an essay was present for me. The introduction and conclusion resonated with one another. The transitions within the central part felt natural. The overall goal of the piece was achieved. I liked the quote at the end to enhance the personal experience.

*Checkg* I appreciated how you tied your connection to nature to the different time periods in your life and included what was happening at the time you wrote the essay. I would have been left wondering if you had only included past experiences.

*Checkg* The mention of your geographic location helped me see your environment and the type of nature you encountered in each place.

*Checkg* Towards the end you mention that those impressions of nature had returned to your life and were more clear to you now, along with your new appreciation for all that it meant to you as a child. That resonated with me for some recent experiences of my own.

Lasting Impressions: Your personal essay has opened my mind for possible essays of my own. I have always had a very defined version of essays that brings feelings of school assignments. Though I didn’t mind writing them, they never felt like a creative writing format for me. The ones I wrote were required and usually regarding some historical facts, etc. Very bland and sort of boring. I am inspired to try this writing format to pass along details of my life for our kids and future generations.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

Celebrating you with an Anniversary Review.
19
19
Review of LOVING A GHOST  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi Jen Ricci Author Icon, this is a review of "LOVING A GHOST.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: An interesting piece open to different interpretations, which always intrigues me. It took reading through it a few times to absorb the imagery and achieve the tone put forth, but I felt by the end that I had a firm hold on the cadence of the piece and it was well worth the extra time spent. The gothic and dark genres come through for me.

*Checkg* Overall tone. From the beginning line to the last, the dark aspect is present.

*Checkg* Consistency. The feeling of sadness and longing carries through the entire piece.

*Checkg* Wording. Crater, void, limbo, energies, madness. Each of these terms evoked images and feelings that carried me along.

*Starg* Hiccup/Speed Bump. The only time I felt pulled out of the piece was the line about the pets. It jarred me a little and disrupted the flow that had started strong. It could be just me. For me, the mention of pets puts me in mind of contemporary/modern times and perhaps a sense of normalcy. (Caring for them, practicality.) So the overall tone of darkness and ethereal occurrences was jarred by something I consider more mundane and everyday.

Lasting Impressions: The piece lingers in my mind. I can turn it over and reexamine it to find different nuances and meanings. She speaks of him being an illusion that is now gone, but I am left feeling as though she is a ghost of the person she was before everything happened. I felt that deep pit in the beginning and by the end, it felt as though she was wandering through life bereft of her own sanity.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
20
20
Review of 26 Paychecks  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, Annette Author Icon this is a review of "26 Paychecks .

I am excited to see a new activity. *Smile*

What I like about the new activity:
*ConfettiG* It's new! (Of course!)
*ConfettiB* Encourages exploration of new (or not used as much) areas of WDC.
*ConfettiR* Multiple opportunities throughout the year.
*ConfettiO* Rewards as you go along and not just at the end.
*ConfettiV* Generous offer of vacation paychecks in consideration of life's chaos.
*ConfettiP* Creative assignments that can lead to meeting other members of WDC.

My only reservation about the activity is how many tasks will be assigned per period and the balance of time dedicated to each of those tasks. My outlook for that concern is that it is likely there will be an element of 'weight' in regard to each task for each period. In other words, two smaller tasks plus one more lengthy or time consuming one.

What would be your favorite paychecks (prizes)?
GPs of some nominal amount. The reason I love these is because I can use them to reward/gift other members for their written work, items reviewed, etc. I love seeing GPs come in because I know I can get to sending them back out!

What would be your favorite tasks?
Relatively short ones for part of the assignment, so we can get most of it done quickly, then focus on any longer element for that period. I also love the idea of having us do reviews or comments for other members. It inspires some of us (ahem, me) to climb out of their shell and interact more.

Why are you giving the star rating that you are assigning?
I gave the 5 star rating because:
*StarG* It's new!
*StarG* Organized in an easy to understand format.
*StarG* Comes from a member who has run other successful and fun activities.
*StarG* Looks promising for entertaining and challenging tasks.
*StarG* Always grateful for another opportunity to earn GPs, so I can pass them along to others.

Thank you for this new opportunity for everyone!

*Snow4* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
21
21
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Ziglet Author Icon, this is a review of "TheChase: A Shiner BockenheimerAdventure.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: Shiner is quite the dog with a great sense for adventure and a good heart. He finds trouble, but makes his way out of it and helps someone else along the way, too. A heartwarming story with action and humor.

*Checkg* Interesting quirk that it is only the kids that can hear the dogs. It gives the story (and stories) a feature that can help spur on twists to the plot and create humorous circumstances.

*Checkg* Good dialogue between the characters. It helps set the stage without having to rely on mainly narration.

*Checkg* Funny and accurate description of Shiner’s personality and point of view. I can picture what he is doing and how he is acting from his dialogue. His actions and words fit the character. I could hear his voice in my head as I read the story.

*Starg* This is a ‘maybe’ comment because it is based upon my experience and perception. A kindergartner might not be able to read the name ‘Shiner’ on the collar. As the reader, I expected him to learn Shiner’s name by Shiner telling it to him telepathically.

Lasting Impressions: I think you have a good thing going here. I could see these adventures in print as short stories enhanced with illustrations sprinkled throughout the books. I think these would be good for a teacher reading to young classes (grades K-2) and then for the kids a little older (grades 3-4) to begin reading on their own. I’m just giving a ballpark of reading ability from experience.

The one additional comment/suggestion that I will offer is that, especially with young kids, some stories can be just a silly diversion and fun to read, while others will have an underlying lesson for the kids that you address after reading. This struck me as a good one to talk to them about not wondering off alone and how scary it was for both Shiner and David. Not all stories have to have a lesson, but if you can both entertain and leave an important impression on a more serious topic, it’s always a good takeaway, in my opinion.

Thank you for sharing your work with us. Best wishes for you and Shiner!

*Ornament1G* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
22
22
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Rio'sReality Author Icon, this is a review of "Chapter Two — The House Lights.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: Chapter two picks right up where one left off, and we see more of our main character’s personal life. The crux of the conflict within him regarding pursuit of his future is revealed. It is one that many readers can relate to and expands our view of him. The scenes pull at my emotions for him and the choices he must make.

Details:

*Checkg* Consistency. The flow is still short and to the point, pulling the reader through the story at a fairly quick pace.

*Checkg* Purposeful dialogue. Provides interplay between the characters and furthers the story.

*Checkg* Character interactions. The two secondary characters highlight the conflict within our main character. I can feel the invisible scale that keeps tipping side to side as he faces his future.

*Starg* Surroundings/Environment. You have a way with words for describing the world around him. It shows us everything from his perspective, which puts us more in the moment. I missed that in this chapter, was looking for it. It was there for the interactions between characters, which was satisfying, but I was also looking for those bits of wit in regard to his house, the school, etc.

Lasting Impressions: I’m firmly in the main character’s shoes, feeling his dilemma. The conflict is not necessarily one that I would experience myself, so to be so in the moment within this story is a telling factor for me. The short sentences and potent dialogue are appealing. My personal preference would see more of the clever descriptions of the surroundings added in future installments.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Turkey* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
23
23
Review of Wrong Turn  
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi Phantom Reader Author Icon, this is a review of "Wrong Turn.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: A poignant tale that packs a punch in just a few words. The dialogue puts us right there with Eric and his group of storm chasers in some hole-in-the-wall bar out in the middle of nowhere Texas. The tale within a tale has a star that we never meet but leaves us with the haunting knowledge of a life gone too soon. We see how it has affected those who knew her for a time and then get to decide what lesson we take from the whole experience.

Details:

*Checkg* Good introduction. I appreciate being thrown into the deep end right off the bat.

*Checkg* Real characters. Their interactions with Eric and reactions to each other bring them to life.

*Checkg* Vivid dialogue. I love learning about the story and characters through their dialogue as opposed to plain narration.

*Starg* The dialogue where they are trying to remember which girl they are talking about was a little muddled for me to try and keep track of who was saying what.

*Checkg* Deeper characters than at first glance. These guys seem like they would be one stick short of a full bunch considering what they do for a living, but then we meet them. Rough on the surface with softer insides. Renato talks a good game of gruff about the girl, but he is the one who remembers her name. Homer is left with that lasting regret, though ultimately it was her decision.

Lasting Impressions: What stays with me about this story is that we know nothing about Mel beyond what we learn from these two guys. She could have a huge family that misses her or maybe she was an orphan with no one to notice she was gone… except for these guys. In a short amount of time, she made an impression on them. They passed it on to Eric and he passed it along to the world. The underlying message for me is that ‘we matter’. Big or small, our marks on the world last.
There were quite a few more messages stuck in there. Don’t take life for granted. If you want something, go after it no matter what the cost. It only takes a second for life to change forever. Big messages in a short story. Nice job. *Smile*

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Turkey* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
24
24
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi tophatfiddle Author Icon, this is a review of "Thousand+ Words for Nov. 14, 2025.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: In 1000+ words, I was transported to a pocket of time in the quiet stillness of space. We jump right into the story with two active characters (along with a host of sleeping ones) that give us hints at the overall plot, some history, and a current problem. The situation is a good hook, and it ends with a nice cliffhanger.

Details:

*Checkg* Good visual and sound descriptions. (Cruiser’s drool, the panels, putting on the headset, beeping waking him up, alarm sounding)

*Starg* Remember to address the other senses – smell, taste, feel. Added naturally (and not overdone or done too close together) these descriptions enhance the setting and draw the reader into being present with the characters.

*Checkg* Helpful use of sci-fi terminology. Not overly done. Terms used were easily understandable for readers who might not regularly read sci-fi (me).

*Checkg* Dialogue with a purpose. I could hear the characters’ voices in my head. The interactions helped further the current scene, the overall plot, and helped expand the reader’s knowledge of the characters themselves.

*Starg* Run on sentences. When writing drafts, sometimes it comes out as a stream of consciousness. For the reader, it can be overwhelming. Editing it into a more refined sentence structure makes it easier to consume and helps establish flow.

*Starg* Transitions – flashbacks/memories. These can serve a purpose when used sparingly. The one with Tammy and Doug feels appropriate. How it is included in the entire chapter can be slightly confusing. Consider using something to set it apart from the rest of the scene – italics, a header/footer for the section, etc.

*Checkg* Good foreshadowing. The problems with the stasis pods. There was an odd feeling about the interaction between Tammy and Doug. What are Doug’s intentions? What happened with Wild Bill? Details sprinkled throughout the scene that keep pulling the reader forward and keep them wondering what will happen, what did happen?

Lasting Impressions: A good quick read for the beginning to an intriguing storyline. Refinement in future drafts will improve upon what has already been established. I’m left thinking about the characters and the plot with questions about both. That, combined with the cliffhanger, makes me want to read more.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Turkey* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
25
25
Review by Maddie Pot o... Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Rio'sReality Author Icon, this is a review of "Chapter 1 Echos Of The Street.

Please keep in mind that these are my perceptions of this piece. These comments should be considered constructive criticism and are not suggestions to change your work.

Overall: Gritty. Intriguing. Leaves the reader with a clear impression of the world and a solid hook that makes you want to know more about the characters, their lives, and their problems.

Details:
*Checkg* Vivid descriptions that play upon the reader’s senses.
*Checkg* Good cadence. There is an ebb and flow that pulls the reader along.
*Checkg* Meaningful dialogue. Short and to the point, it adds to the story and helps paint the picture.
*Checkg* Believable characters. They came to life in just one short chapter.
*Starg* The only comment I could make on improvement is in regards to the use of the word ‘foiling’. “foiling with the interior lint” – I’m not sure if that is used in the correct context. Even if it is, it was the only hiccup for me as I read through the piece.

Lasting Impressions: Gangster/crime family/mob stories are not one of my chosen genres. In fact, I rarely read them. If I try, I generally lose interest quickly. This was not the case here. I was drawn into the story and invested in the main character – without ever knowing his name.

Thank you for sharing your work with us.

*Turkey* Maddie

"The Power Reviewers Group

A review sig for Power members to share
89 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 4 25 per page   < >