\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED ITEMS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://webx1.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sindbad
Review Requests: ON
2,433 Public Reviews Given
2,433 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I want an honest opinion
I'm good at...
I am sensitive to minor details.
Favorite Genres
Any
Least Favorite Genres
Horror and erotic
Favorite Item Types
Science fiction
Least Favorite Item Types
Erotic
I will not review...
Religious, or illogical.
Public Reviews
<   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  ...   >
1
1
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Taraib

That was a great read. This chapter does an excellent job of setting a strong, atmospheric foundation for the story. Here is a detailed review of "Game of the Gods - Chapter 1: Warrior of the Frost."
❄️ Detailed Review of "Warrior of the Frost"
Overall Impression
This is a compelling and atmospheric opening chapter. It immediately establishes a harsh, unforgiving setting and introduces the protagonist, Theminor, with a good balance of action, internal reflection, and cultural context. The chapter successfully grounds the reader in the deca'lar culture and raises the stakes dramatically with the sudden, tragic death of Jorg, ending on a strong note of lingering danger and emotional turmoil.
Strengths
1. Atmosphere and Setting
The writing excels at creating a visceral sense of cold and isolation. Phrases like "barren wind pushed at the bundle of furs, biting through the many layers," and the description of the "blinding snow" and "white silence" immerse the reader in the arctic environment. The setting is not just a backdrop; it is an active antagonist, leading directly to Jorg's death.
2. Character Introduction and Internal Conflict
Theminor is introduced effectively. We learn about his personal drive (the "taking," or battle lust), his heritage (deca'lar, or Warrior of the Frost), and his emotional depth (the memory of his mother, the shame of the scar). His internal conflict—between the shame of failing and the urge to turn back versus the powerful drive of his taking—makes him a relatable and complex protagonist. The focus on his blue eyes being "unnatural for a deca'lar" is an excellent touch of subtle character mystery.
3. Pacing and Action
The pacing is deliberate, starting slow with the arduous journey and internal reflection, and then suddenly accelerating with the ice chasm scene. This scene is the chapter's climax, marked by:
* Tension Building: The "scraping sound" building to the "sound of a hundred avalanches."
* Impact: Jorg's immediate and horrifying death.
* Heroism: Theminor's desperate, near-successful leap and action, which quickly establishes him as the strongest and most courageous of the group.
4. Worldbuilding and Culture
The chapter effectively introduces key cultural terms that lend authenticity to the barbarian society:
* The taking: The central drive for battle and adventure.
* deca'lar: The term for a Warrior of the Frost.
* dunkai: The term for the clan head/leader, and the importance of courage and challenge.
This context is woven in naturally during Theminor's reflections, providing information without bogging down the narrative.
Areas for Potential Improvement
1. Dialogue and Voice
The dialogue is sparse, which fits the somber and harsh environment. However, the exchange with Igloth at the end feels a little too direct. Igloth's line:
> "But we may never reach Milay. We may never see our families again."
>
It expresses the theme clearly, but it might be more impactful if it was framed as a quieter, more desperate question or a statement of fear, rather than a fully reasoned plea. A subtle refinement could enhance the emotional weight of his anxiety.
2. Descriptive Refinement
While the descriptions of cold are strong, some descriptions are slightly generic. For example, describing his hair as "shoulder length, stringy hair." Stringy often has a negative connotation. Given that he is a warrior on his "taking," a more powerful or specific descriptor (e.g., braided, weather-matted, wind-whipped) might better suit a deca'lar.
3. Minor Exposition Point
The explanation of the dunkai and challenges in the final section, while good for worldbuilding, is a bit of an extended internal monologue immediately following a dramatic death and a shift in leadership. While it justifies Theminor's sudden emergence as the new leader, it slightly slows the momentum gained from the chasm scene. It could potentially be broken up or woven more directly into Theminor's current thoughts on taking control.
Conclusion and Outlook
"Warrior of the Frost" is a successful chapter that achieves its primary goals: establishing the setting, defining the protagonist's cultural and personal motivations, and raising the stakes through tragedy. Theminor's new, reluctant leadership role, coupled with the emotional weight of Jorg's death and the lingering threat represented by the "large, yellow eyes" at the end, creates strong anticipation for Chapter 2. The core theme of courage vs. despair in the face of an indifferent world is well-developed.
Would you like me to focus on a specific element of the story, such as the worldbuilding or Theminor's leadership, or summarize the main events?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
2
2
Review of Torn  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
RadioShea

This is a powerful and emotionally resonant poem, crafted skillfully in the form of a Sestina.
🌟 Overall Impression
Your poem, "Torn," is an emotionally devastating and technically impressive piece. The theme of a mother's relentless, decade-long pain after her son is taken away is handled with raw sincerity. The Sestina form, which is notoriously difficult, is executed very well here, weaving the six end words—pain, sun, floor, mother, son, torn—through the six stanzas and the envoi to create a cyclical, almost obsessive sense of grief. The poem successfully conveys the constant, gnawing quality of the mother's heartbreak, contrasting her present success ("Now she reigns the office top-floor") with her internal devastation.
📝 Detailed Review and Analysis
Strengths
* Mastery of the Sestina Form: The repeating end words feel natural and are leveraged to emphasize the core themes.
* "Torn" and "pain" are central to the mother's state.
* "Mother" and "son" define the relationship and the loss.
* "Sun" (representing hope, life, and warmth) and "floor" (representing despair, falling, and the bottom) create a strong, tangible contrast for her emotional journey. The relentless re-use of these words perfectly mirrors the relentless nature of her grief.
* Strong Imagery and Metaphor:
* The image of her "plunges to the floor" in the first stanza immediately establishes the depth of her physical and emotional collapse.
* The contrast between the "office top-floor" and her "soul is torn" is a brilliant, concise metaphor for her outwardly successful yet inwardly broken life.
* The "screaming eyes face the pane / and attempt to drink in the sun, / but only snowflakes block and grow" is a stunning image. It powerfully illustrates her desperate need for light/hope, which is cruelly blocked by the cold, sterile reality (the snowflakes/pane).
* Thematic Depth: The poem goes beyond simple sorrow to explore the very definition of motherhood ("She ponders, what makes a mother," and the rhetorical questions in Stanza 4). This elevates the poem from a lament to a profound meditation on identity and loss.
Tips for Improvement
* Clarity in Stanza 2's Transition:
* The shift to considering the son's perspective is important, but the line, "Would he want to see such a mother / with tears and knees gripping the floor?" is slightly ambiguous. Is she worried he'd be ashamed, or is this the pain of knowing she can't be the strong mother she wishes she could be for him? While Sestinas thrive on ambiguity, a slight sharpening here might strengthen the emotional punch.
* Rhythm and Flow:
* In Stanza 5, the quotes attributed to "they" ("Too young to be a mother." "She herself must still grow." "To raise a child will bring certain pain") are perfect in their content, but the flow surrounding them is a little broken. Consider how to integrate the accusatory voices before the action of them floating away with the baby:
> Current: “Too young to be a mother.” / “She herself must still grow.” / “To raise a child will bring certain pain,” / they claimed before floating from the floor...
> A thought for testing: They claimed "Too young to be a mother." / "She herself must still grow." / "To raise a child will bring certain pain," / before floating from the floor... (This is a small point, but worth considering for a smoother read.)
>
* Envoi/Tercet: The final three lines are crucial in a Sestina.
* The pane of snow releases a sliver of sun (A momentary release/hope)
* upon a cold floor, embracing a mother (The floor as a place of rest/acceptance)
* who just discovered no baby will grow where one was once torn. (This ending is powerful but slightly cryptic. Does "no baby will grow" mean she can't have another child, or is it a final, crushing realization about the permanence of the first loss? If it's the latter, it provides a chilling, final closure to her struggle for hope.)
🎯 Next Steps
This is an excellent poem that honors the difficulty of the Sestina form while delivering a gut-wrenching emotional narrative. The way you contrasted the literal floor (office, collapse) with the metaphorical torn (soul, baby) is very effective.
My honest rating would be 5 Stars.
Would you like me to highlight the six end words in each of the six stanzas to show how perfectly the Sestina pattern (1-2-3-4-5-6, 6-1-5-2-4-3, etc.) was followed?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
3
3
Review of SEASON ONE  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Ben W. Gardner

🎬 SEASON ONE: EPISODE 1 - THE PROTOTYPE 🚀
Summary of the Screenplay Excerpt
The excerpt details an emergency National Security Council (NSC) meeting at the White House, called by CIA Director Bill Murraugh to brief President Forest on an unprecedented situation in Roswell, Georgia. The crisis revolves around Michael Angel, a retired Navy SEAL and billionaire private inventor who possesses revolutionary, non-conventional technology.
* The Incident: Angel was arrested after a UFO sighting but released after a judge dismissed the charges, ruling the police action was out of line.
* The Confrontation: Upon returning to his property, Angel deployed an impenetrable energy barrier that renders conventional weapons and military force (including an Air Reserve squadron) completely ineffective, humiliating the US military on live broadcast.
* The Technology: Angel has a silent anti-gravity backpack flyer and a powerful supercomputer/AI named ESADS (Electronically Simulated Artificial Development System), which he uses to broadcast the confrontation. He also possesses a sophisticated, non-lethal weapon that can incapacitate a sniper.
* The Standoff: Angel asserts his constitutional rights (citing the Posse Comitatus Act and property amendments) against the government's claim of National Security to seize his technology. He openly mocks the officials' incompetence and greed, refusing to surrender his inventions, which he says he developed, built, and owns.
* Escalation: The officials discover Angel has been launching his own satellites from his backyard, including a large cylindrical object recently placed in a stationary orbit over Georgia, confirming the advanced and unknown nature of his technology.
Key Characters and Roles
| Character | Role and Significance |
|---|---|
| President Forest | The annoyed, irritable, and later incredulous U.S. President, forced to confront a crisis that makes his administration look foolish. |
| Michael Angel | The brilliant, wealthy, retired Navy SEAL inventor. He is confident, sarcastic, and uses his knowledge of the law and technology to defy the U.S. government. |
| Bill Murraugh | Director of the CIA, who briefs the President on the initial report and the gravity of Angel's technology. |
| Bill Freer | Director of the FBI, who provides details on Angel's technological setup (ESADS, satellite links). |
| General David Applehoff | Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (CJS), who is defensive and embarrassed by the military's inability to penetrate Angel's defenses. |
| ESADS (OS) | Angel's Electronically Simulated Artificial Development System (AI). It speaks in a pleasant male voice and manages Angel's technology and public broadcasting. |
Central Conflicts and Themes
| Conflict/Theme | Description |
|---|---|
| Individual vs. State | Angel strongly defends his private property and intellectual rights against what he views as an illegal military attempt at confiscation, directly citing the Constitution and the Posse Comitatus law. |
| Technological Disparity | Angel's inventions (impenetrable force field, silent anti-grav flyer, weapon-disrupting technology, AI supercomputer, personal satellite network) completely outclass and render U.S. military assets useless, causing national security panic. |
| Public Humiliation | Angel intentionally live-broadcasts the military's failure to the world via the Internet, which is quickly picked up by CNN, humiliating the government and military leadership. |
| Conspiracy & Secrecy | The revelation that Angel has secretly launched at least 18 smaller objects and one large satellite highlights a massive intelligence failure by U.S. agencies. |

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
4
4
Review of SEASON ONE  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Ben W. Gardner

The review that I could fathom is written below.
📝 Logline
Under military siege, sardonic inventor Mike Angel rejects the Air Force's demand to surrender his revolutionary space drive, instead proposing a conditional cooperation deal with the President to prevent its weaponization and leverage its benefits for scientific advancement.
📌 Key Plot Points
* The Standoff: Air Force Major attempts to intimidate Mike Angel into surrendering the space drive, citing national security concerns and Mike's lack of resources to protect it. Mike, relaxed in a loud Hawaiian shirt, mocks the Major and refuses, claiming the drive is safest in his hands for purely scientific use.
* Confronting the President: President Forest calls, expressing deep fear over the drive's destructive potential, referencing a recent test that left a 2000-foot-deep crater. Mike acknowledges the weapon potential (likening it to atomic power) but states the drive's primary purpose is space travel. He fears any government, including the US, would misuse it and destabilize the world's balance of power.
* The Cooperation Offer: Mike shifts from refusal to an "executive closing a deal" tone, proposing a plan: he retains full possession, but will share the fruits of his research. Benefits include ferry service to the ISS, satellite launches, and safe nuclear waste disposal at a fraction of the current cost.
* Terms of the Deal: Mike requests only cooperation and to be left alone to pursue his work. He asks for government assistance in ordering a new, improved passenger vehicle from Lockheed. He threatens to move his entire operation—including his house and AI—to a remote location like Siberia if the US refuses to cooperate.
* Technical Progress: In his hangar-sized workshop, Mike tests a new communication system with his prototype ship millions of miles away, verifying there is no light-speed limitation for communication. The ship also notes a slight time-of-year clock desynchronization, prompting Mike to reference Einstein's theories (suggesting time dilation).
* The AI's Name: A running gag reveals the full name of the House Computer (OS) is ESADS, which the AI learns stands for "Eat Shit And Die, Sucker," much to Mike's nervous embarrassment.
* Stalemate Continues: After a week, new, tougher Marines replace the Major and reservists. When the President calls again, Mike remains firm: his way or no way. He dismisses NASA's claims of jurisdiction as relying on outdated technology ("glorified firecracker").
👤 Character Dynamics
| Character | Role & Attitude | Key Interaction |
|---|---|---|
| Mike Angel | Confident, sardonic, genius inventor. Views himself as a superior, ethical steward of the technology. | Dismisses the Air Force Major's threats; negotiates directly with the President from his lawn chair. |
| Air Force Major | Aggressive, by-the-book military/NSA operative. | Pressures Mike to surrender the "cache of weapons" but is easily dismissed by Mike. |
| President Forest (OS) | Weary, stressed, and genuinely fearful of the power Mike possesses. | Argues Mike is a "dangerous man," but eventually listens to the cooperation offer. |
| House Computer (OS) / ESADS | Highly intelligent, cynical AI with a parental/petulant tone toward Mike. | Provides comic relief and technical assistance; complains about the name Mike gave it. |
| Prototype (OS) | Mike's sentient, obedient spacecraft AI. | Executes a high-speed communications test, confirming instantaneous transmission. |
💬 Best Quotes
* Mike Angel: "Military Intelligence? Now there's an oxymoron!"
* Mike Angel (to the President): "I'm not prepared to become 'Shiva, Destroyer of Worlds'."
* Mike Angel (on cooperation): "All I'm asking for is a little cooperation and to be left alone, basically."
* House Computer (OS): "Most of your brain is in liquid helium at minus 273 degrees Celsius! Siberian winter should be like Death Valley to you." (Responding to Mike's joke about moving to cold Siberia)

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
5
5
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
fullquiver

I did find this interesting story in the reward section and story review: "Things That Go Thump in the Night" 📖
"Things That Go Thump in the Night" is a deeply personal and emotionally raw biographical piece that effectively captures the overwhelming anxiety, exhaustion, and internal conflict faced by a single mother juggling immense responsibilities. The narrative is a compelling exploration of generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), panic attacks, and the struggle for self-forgiveness and resilience, all framed against the backdrop of an impossibly hectic life.
Key Strengths and Impressions 💪
* Vivid Portrayal of a Panic Attack: The opening scene is incredibly powerful and immediately immerses the reader in the narrator's terror. The description of the invisible hands choking her, the vise-like chest pressure, and the temporary paralysis is a classic and viscerally felt depiction of a nocturnal panic attack or possibly sleep paralysis, making the experience frighteningly real.
* Relatable Internal Conflict: The story's greatest strength is the relentless internal dialogue. The narrator's "compulsive thinker" and "drill sergeant" persona ("Get a grip!," "You are such a failure") warring with her vulnerability, fear, and shame creates a deeply authentic character. Many readers, particularly those juggling work, school, and family, will relate to the feeling of being hyper-responsible and perpetually overwhelmed.
* The Power of Connection: The role of the friend, Sandy, serves as a critical emotional anchor. She is portrayed as "Jesus with skin on," a necessary, earthly extension of the narrator's faith that provides immediate, tangible solace and validation. This highlights the vital importance of human connection in battling mental health issues.
* Effective Pacing and Structure: The story is structured around a central event (the nighttime episode) and its aftermath (the decision to call the doctor). The narrative successfully conveys the relentless, cyclical nature of her stress, moving from the domestic chaos of the morning rush to her job, then to schoolwork, and finally to the doctor's office. This shows why she couldn't prioritize her health earlier.
* Thoughtful Exploration of Fear: The story delves beyond a simple fear of illness to reveal a profound fear of abandonment and its consequence on her children. Her reflections on death, faith, and purpose ("To live is Christ, to die is gain") provide an intelligent, philosophical layer to her anxiety, showing she's not afraid of the afterlife, but of the hole her absence would leave in her loved ones' lives.
Areas for Improvement and Tips 📝
* Juggling Too Many Threads: While the detail adds context, the sheer volume of responsibilities (single mother of five, bus driver, student, client sessions) can make the narrative feel slightly crowded. Trimming a few minor, less-developed details (like the specifics of the TSS reports or the barium swallow test) could tighten the focus on the central emotional and medical crisis.
* Show, Don't Tell in Dialogue: The phone conversation with the receptionist is a place where the narrator's inner thoughts about the receptionist's perkiness are told directly to the reader. A slight tweak to the dialogue or description could show the perceived lack of concern, making it feel less like a narrative statement and more integrated into the scene. For example, focusing on the mechanical quality of the receptionist's voice: "She repeated the next available time in the same cheerful, non-committal tone, as if I'd just told her I stubbed my toe."
* Stylistic Polish: The piece uses some informal or slightly repetitive phrasing, like the constant self-scolding and the phrase "know in my knower." While these phrases are authentic to the narrator's internal voice, slight variations could enhance the literary quality. For example, instead of repeated use of "I scolded myself," varying it with "I chastised my inner child" or "My conscience snapped" could add flavor.
* Ambiguous Diagnosis: While the doctor's potential diagnoses (cancers, heart disease) dramatically heighten the tension, the final interaction, where the doctor prescribes Xanax and Lexapro while listing serious life-threatening tests, feels a bit jarring. The story successfully leads the reader to believe the root cause is overwhelming stress and anxiety, but then leaves the medical mystery ("You could have lung cancer...") unsolved. The prescriptions, however, strongly suggest the doctor believes the primary, treatable issue is the severe anxiety and depression.
Overall Conclusion ⭐
"Things That Go Thump in the Night" is a candid and moving account of a person fighting a complex, often invisible battle against anxiety and the pressures of modern life. It is highly successful in creating empathy for the narrator, who is striving for perfection but feels defeated by her own exhaustion and sense of failure.
The story offers an essential message: the greatest 'thump in the night' is often the sound of a panic-stricken heart, and sometimes, a mother's greatest act of self-love is simply calling the doctor and accepting help. The final scene, with the prescriptions in hand and the simple need for a nap, is a perfect, exhausted ending to a draining, honest day.
Keep writing! The honesty you infuse into the internal monologue is truly captivating and powerful...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
6
6
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

That's a powerful and evocative poem, "A Full-Fledged Gripe: A Mood to Swallow."
Here is a detailed review, focusing on honesty, encouragement, and respect, with an overall impression and tips for improvement.
📝 Detailed Review: A Full-Fledged Gripe: A Mood to Swallow
Overall Impression: A Tapestry of Contradictions
This poem presents a fascinating and deliberately jarring juxtaposition of imagery and emotion. The title, "A Full-Fledged Gripe: A Mood to Swallow," perfectly sets the tone, promising a confrontation with internal bitterness or discontent. The piece feels like a rapid-fire collage of human experience—from historical suffering to fleeting joy, from personal failure to defiant ego. The language is punchy, raw, and full of internal contradictions, successfully capturing the chaotic, mixed nature of a "gripe" that is hard to suppress. The rhythm is strong and propulsive, often driven by the tight AABB rhyme scheme.
Stanza-by-Stanza Analysis
Stanza 1: The Weight of History
This stanza opens with heavy, dark imagery: "tunnels, shackles and chains," and "dogs on the brains." It immediately introduces themes of oppression, dehumanization, and suffering. The transition in the third and fourth lines, "Glory to Heaven, lives down the drains - / Sunny, then rainbows - viewed once it rains," is excellent. It contrasts the noble concept of "Glory to Heaven" with the grim reality of lost lives, suggesting that true beauty or hope (rainbows, sunshine) is only genuinely appreciated after enduring great pain ("once it rains"). This sets up the poem's central theme of contrast.
Stanza 2: Fleeting Joy and Lingering Regret
Here, the mood shifts sharply to a more contemporary, personal scene of enjoyment: "Holding a beauty, while strolling along," a "fabulous song," and "money's still strong." However, this image of blissful escape is brutally undercut by the final line: "Family and friends watching victories gone wrong!" This line is highly effective. It suggests that even in moments of success or pleasure, the mind is haunted by past failures or the pain of loved ones, reinforcing the 'gripe' that cannot be ignored.
Stanza 3: The Absurdity of Mood
This is perhaps the most surreal and rhythmically intense stanza. The mood itself becomes a physical, absurd entity: "A bad mood starts early, then gets going later." The baseball metaphors ("homer," "tater") feel slightly disconnected but contribute to a sense of aggressive, almost manic energy. The images of "circus clown skater" and "Ecstasy’s burden’s a new air inflater" verge on the absurd, powerfully illustrating how a persistent bad mood can distort and inflate even positive or escapist experiences into something bizarre or burdensome.
Stanza 4: Defensive Isolation
This stanza focuses on a defensive, cynical response to the world. The shift from "minuses" to a desired "plus" captures the aspirational yet frustrated core of the gripe. The images of being "thrown under a bus" and the act of choosing to "deflect all the fuss" convey a feeling of isolation, betrayal, and a conscious decision to retreat from genuine connection ("Bother relating"). The missing hammers suggest frustration with an inability to fix or build.
Stanza 5: The Cost of Ego
The concluding stanza brings the focus to performance and impermanence. "Strutting like talent makes you stay on their toes" speaks to a defensive ego, which ironically leads to instability: "Doors which were open might suddenly close." The final couplet is the strongest close: "Life’s a reminder of yesterday’s pose! / Chasing a blossom - a new, wilted rose." The image of the "wilted rose" perfectly encapsulates the core emotion—the pursuit of something beautiful or new that is already decaying, reinforcing the pessimism and the full-fledged nature of the central gripe.
Tips for Improvement
* Vary the Meter and Rhyme: The use of an extremely consistent AABB rhyme scheme and a very tight meter gives the poem a strong, driving rhythm, but it occasionally makes the language feel constrained or predictable. Experimenting with an ABCB or AABB/CDCD structure, or breaking the tight tetrameter, could allow certain lines to breathe and carry more emotional weight.
* Clarify Abstract Metaphors: Stanza 3 is very bold, but lines like "Each day’s a homer, a pitch that’s a tater" and "Sharing balloons for each circus clown skater!" feel a bit abstract or arbitrary compared to the grounded imagery in Stanza 1. Consider refining these lines to connect more explicitly to the theme of the "gripe" or the 'burden of ecstasy' to maintain narrative cohesion.
* Harness the Juxtaposition: The poem's strength lies in its contrasts (shackles vs. rainbows, singing vs. lost victories). Lean into this contrast even more. For example, by slightly softening the language of the 'good' moments, the final lines of conflict will hit with even greater force.
Rating Suggestion
I would rate this poem 4 Stars. It's a highly successful piece of emotional writing, original in its construction, and powerful in its message. The tight structure and vivid, albeit sometimes disconnected, imagery create a memorable reading experience.
Would you like me to focus on a specific stanza or aspect of the poem, like the use of contradiction, for further analysis?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
7
7
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Nemesis

That was an exciting chapter! The tension built up perfectly as Liam and Allison thought they were being chased, only for the revelation that it was Great Uncle Charles.
Here is a detailed review of Chapter 4, "Charisma - The Devil's Gap":
Overall Impression and Strengths
This chapter is a strong, high-energy payoff to the preceding suspense. You've skillfully combined thrilling action with a moment of comedic relief and character development. The writing is fast-paced and engaging, especially the racing scene, and the dialogue feels natural. The initial tension is very well managed; Liam's concern about the following sedan is palpable and is a great way to show off his driving skills.
The revelation that the "threat" is Great Uncle Charles, who simply wanted to race, is an excellent narrative twist. It's funny, unexpected, and instantly humanizes the characters and their extended family environment.
Areas for Improvement and Tips
1. Technical Detail and Flow
* The Trail-Braking Explanation: The description of trail-braking: "It is the art of braking and accelerating at the same time. The purpose is to shift the cars weight from one or two tires to the others. This allows for more pavement adhesion and ultimately faster cornering speeds." This is technically accurate, but it interrupts the flow of the action.
* Tip: Try to show this technique in action rather than telling the reader what it is. Focus on the visceral experience. For example, you could shift the focus to Allison's perspective: "The car hunkered down, Liam's foot feathering the brake and gas simultaneously, somehow gluing the tires to the road through a corner that should have had them sliding into a ditch. 'Holy! You were accelerating when I would have been slamming the brakes!' Allison gasped." This integrates the detail without stopping the scene.
2. Characterizing the Family Introduction
* Uncle Charles and Aunt Ethyl: The introduction of these two characters is great. Uncle Charles is immediately colorful and entertaining, and Aunt Ethyl's "dither" creates a nice contrast. The line where Charles doubts Allison is an accountant is a perfect, amusing moment of tension between him and Liam.
* The Valet Collision: The bowling-over of the valet, Leo Mansfield, is a strong beat of physical comedy and consequence. It humanizes Liam when he profusely apologizes and tips Leo.
* Clarity: The description of Leo's injury is slightly vague: "A small amount of blood oozed from the surface wound." If Leo is well enough to joke, keep it minor. The interaction works well as a quick moment of family familiarity—Liam recognizes a "long time servant of the family."
3. Setting and Atmosphere
* The Arrival: You mention there are "cars and people everywhere" at the home, which is why Liam had to slow down. However, when Liam charges out of the car to confront the sedan, no one seems to react to the high-speed entry, the screeching halt, or the subsequent collision with the valet until Leo speaks up much later.
* Tip: Briefly mention the stares or confusion of the party guests/valets when Liam charges the sedan. This would make the scene feel more alive and less like the main characters are in a vacuum. A sentence like, "A dozen heads turned from the front porch, watching the luxury sedan and the charging figure of Liam," could suffice.
Summary
This is an excellent, pivotal chapter. It delivers on the suspense promised by the car chase, introduces a colorful new character (Uncle Charles), and gives a glimpse into Liam's wealthy, established, and somewhat eccentric background. The chapter ends well, successfully transitioning the focus from the car chase to the social setting of the party. You've definitely ramped up the excitement!

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
8
8
Review of Soul Mates  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hi
Late Cheri Annemos

That's a lovely and poignant story titled "Soul Mates." Here is a detailed review.
💖 Review of "Soul Mates" by Cheri Annemos
"Soul Mates" is a touching, nostalgic, and ultimately heartwarming short story that centers on Lucky, a devoted husband remembering his wife, Becky, on what would have been their 40th wedding anniversary. The narrative is structured around a journey of memory, literally taking Lucky to significant places from his past with Becky.
🌟 Overall Impression
The story effectively captures the enduring nature of love and the pain of loss. It’s deeply sentimental without being overly saccharine, grounded by the recurring, simple traditions of Pepsi and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The author successfully creates a strong, clear image of a decades-long, joyful relationship. Lucky's final conversation with his daughter, Mandy, provides a comforting and necessary resolution to his day of melancholy reflection, leaving the reader with a feeling of gentle sorrow mixed with deep satisfaction for the life they shared.
✨ Strengths and Positive Feedback
* Emotional Resonance: The story's greatest strength is its ability to evoke genuine emotion. The reader feels Lucky’s love for Becky, his pride in their daughter, and his quiet grief. The final line about Becky not winning the fight with cancer is delivered effectively, giving context to his entire day.
* The Power of Tradition: The central motif of the 2 Pepsi's and Reese's Peanut Butter Cup is exceptionally well-used. It's a simple, affordable tradition born from their first date and first anniversary, making it a perfect symbol of their enduring, unpretentious love.
* Characterization through Dialogue/Action: Becky is painted vividly as a cheerful, impish, and loving woman. Her changing of the song lyrics ("Mandy, you're a fine girl") and her playful, firm stance on naming their potential son (leading to the "It's still a girl" exchange) are fantastic, concise moments that bring her to life.
* Structure and Pacing: The story uses a journey to prompt flashbacks, which is a classic and effective technique. The transitions between the present (Lucky's drive) and the past (high school, the dock, the first house) are smooth and naturally triggered by the locations. The pacing is gentle, matching Lucky's contemplative mood.
💡 Tips for Improvement
* Clarity on Time/Phone Usage: The mention of the "contraptions" (cellphones) and the daughter adding them to her "dataplan" is a little jarring. Since the story relies on a classic, timeless feel, using simpler terms like "mobile phone" or focusing on the connection rather than the technical plan might flow better. The phrase "He snapped the phone shut" suggests an older flip phone, which adds to the classic feel, but the preceding sentence slightly disrupts it.
* Show, Don't Tell (Minimal): The story works well, but a few phrases could be made stronger. For example, instead of, "This discussion was not going the way Lucky had hoped and did not know how to say what was on his heart," you might show his internal struggle or physical agitation before he blurts out, "Wear my ring."
* Consistency of Nickname/Formal Name: While Lucky is the standard, Becky calling him David is used effectively to show she "meant business." Just ensure the distinction remains clear and purposeful throughout the narrative.
✅ Conclusion
"Soul Mates" is a very successful piece of writing. It tells a beautiful, self-contained story about memory, love, and keeping promises, even after loss. The characters of Lucky and Becky are genuinely endearing, and their life together feels authentic. The narrative flow and use of powerful, specific traditions make this a truly memorable read...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
9
9
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
S.L. Key

This looks like an excerpt from a fantasy story titled "The Dawn that Rose from Fire". It focuses on a tense confrontation between the character Alenyah and her friend Berin regarding unwelcome guests in their valley, specifically members of the Stoneborn race.
Here is a detailed review of the provided excerpt:
📝 Story Review: "The Dawn that Rose from Fire" Excerpt
Overall Impression
This excerpt is highly engaging and effectively establishes a powerful sense of tension and deep-seated conflict rooted in past trauma and racial distrust. The opening immediately throws the reader into a high-stakes moment, using strong, visceral internal monologue and dynamic action to drive the scene forward. The world-building, while subtle, introduces interesting racial dynamics between the Fey'ri, Stoneborn, and Rhea (Althea).
Pacing and Structure
The pacing is excellent. The scene begins with Alenyah's rage, escalates with her physical confrontation with Berin, maintains the tension through their dialogue and the mysterious arrival of the Elder Korith, and finally offers a slight decompression in the kitchen with Althea, culminating in a charged moment of decision. The entire sequence is structured to build toward Alenyah reluctantly entering the house, leaving the reader on a compelling, unresolved note.
Characterization and Dialogue
* Alenyah: She is the clear focal point and the most dynamic character. Her rage is palpable, driven by a deep, shared history that the reader is only given glimpses of ("The Dawn that Rose from Fire," "what happened that day," the "Rising"). She is powerful, intimidating, and clearly protective of the Vale's peace. Her sudden shift in the kitchen—from lethal protector to a person capable of half-laughing with Althea—adds a compelling layer of complexity and highlights her close relationship with the Rhea woman. Her reverence for her sword and the mention of the Fylgja offer intriguing cultural details.
* Berin: He serves as the well-meaning, but seemingly naive, foil to Alenyah. His failure to understand her fear and his use of "Cloudy headed" show a stark disconnect between their perspectives, highlighting the difference between his research-driven enthusiasm and Alenyah's lived experience of conflict. His character is anchored by his grief and "manic" projects since his wife Laila's death.
* Korith: The Elder’s sudden appearance and vague, ominous warning ("our problems did not go away when we found safety. And its seems, they are catching up to us") successfully widens the scope of the immediate conflict. He has an authoritative, yet controlled, presence, reinforcing the idea that the threat is larger than just Berin's visitors.
* Althea: She provides crucial emotional relief and grounding. Her domesticity (flour, roast, boots off) contrasts sharply with Alenyah's fury and the political threat. Her relationship with Alenyah feels genuine and warm, instantly humanizing Alenyah and the stakes of her decision.
World-building and Atmosphere
The narrative utilizes subtle but effective world-building elements:
* Racial Tensions: The clear, visceral hatred Alenyah holds for the Stoneborn, juxtaposed with Berin's ease and the reference to their underground lives ("despised the race who lived their entire lives often without seeing the sky"), immediately establishes a history of conflict.
* The Vale: Described as a place of "RELATIVE peace," it feels isolated and hard-won, emphasizing the high cost of disruption.
* Magical Elements: The references to the "Song" (a form of environmental or emotional awareness) and the Fylgja (guardian spirit or familiar) add a distinct fantasy flavor. The "seeping corruption" mentioned on the maps hints at a larger existential threat.
Dialogue and Prose
The prose is direct, sharp, and emotive. Phrases like "struggled not to shake with rage," "ice chips in her eyes," and "The Singer did not smile, staring coldly" are highly effective. The dialogue is natural, driving the plot while revealing character, particularly the contrast between Alenyah's hisses and Berin's reasonable tone.
🛠️ Tips for Improvement
* Clarify the "Rising": The term "Rising" is significant enough to be capitalized, but its meaning is currently vague. If it refers to a specific, pivotal historical event for the Fey'ri or Alenyah, consider weaving in a single, sharper image or brief clause about it earlier to connect her present rage more concretely to that past.
* Korith's Motive: Korith's sudden reappearance and cryptic explanation feel slightly convenient to move the plot. A brief sentence or two acknowledging why he left and how he knew to return might strengthen his role. For example, "I thought you were dead," followed by his explanation, works, but a hint of his outside activities could be added.
* The Stoneborn's Identity: We know they're inside and disarmed, but the excerpt doesn't offer a single detail about who they are (are they soldiers, scholars, or merchants?). Since they are the source of Alenyah's entire conflict, a fleeting visual description or a brief overheard phrase might intensify the atmosphere before Alenyah enters.
Overall, this is a strong, compelling excerpt that successfully builds a foundation of ancient conflict and emotional stakes, leaving the reader eager to follow Alenyah into the house to learn the full extent of Berin's "information."

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
10
10
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hi
PATRICK EDWARDS

This is a detailed review of the story "THE WHATE HOUSE in Innsmouth c1 & C2."
✍️ Overall Impression
This story is a vibrant and atmospheric piece of Lovecraftian horror/mystery, immediately grabbing the reader's attention with its intense setting and bizarre crime. The author successfully establishes a strong sense of dread and chaos through vivid descriptions of the storm and the eerie, fire-damaged "Whate House" (presumably a variation of Lovecraft's 'Whately'). The plot moves quickly from a frantic phone call to the discovery of a grotesque scene, culminating in an unnerving supernatural event. The story is rich in unsettling imagery, particularly the impaled body, the strange statue, and the disappearing sacrificial scene.
However, the narrative is frequently hampered by technical issues—primarily spelling, grammar, and syntax errors—which sometimes make the action difficult to follow and break the otherwise strong immersion. Addressing these issues would significantly elevate the story's impact.
🔦 Strengths of the Narrative
* Atmosphere and Setting: The constant, brutal storm acts as a fantastic, oppressive backdrop, mirroring the chaos and dread of the events. Innsmouth itself, a place known for its sinister reputation and strange inhabitants, is an excellent choice for this kind of mystery.
* Pacing and Hook: The story starts in media res with the urgent phone call, immediately setting a fast pace. The discovery of the impaled reporter and the subsequent entry into the house are excellent hooks, building suspense and culminating in the horrifying reveal of the sacrifice and the creature.
* Vivid Imagery: The descriptions of the corpse on the fence (the barbs cutting the chest and groin), the discovery of the squid-headed, bat-winged statue with a heart in its hand, and the sacrificial scene are all effectively grotesque and genuinely unsettling. They clearly establish the story's genre roots.
* Character Contrast: The dynamic between the narrator, Jake Johnson, who is apprehensive and easily chilled, and his partner, Eric Vandal, who is jovial, thick-mustached, and inexplicably loves the violent storm, provides a great grounding contrast. Vandal's reaction to the final horror ("Tears ran from his eyes") makes his eventual fear more potent.
* Lovecraftian Elements: The mention of Innsmouth and the Whate/Whately family, the presence of a reporter investigating strange families (a common trope), the squid/bat-like statue (reminiscent of Cthulhu or similar entities), the disappearing bodies, and the chanting and strange script firmly place this in the cosmic horror genre.
🛠️ Tips for Improvement
1. Focus on Technical Polish
The most critical area for improvement is editing for clarity and correctness. Numerous errors in spelling, grammar, and syntax disrupt the reader's flow and make comprehension difficult at times.
* Spelling and Typos: Words like "throuigh" (through), "gramants" (garments), "ane" (and), "lense" (lens), "hat l thought" (I had thought), "debries" (debris), "ctrazy" (crazy), "sommothering" (smothering), "momment" (moment), "staining" (standing), "tenacled" (tentacled), and "lounge coat" (used for an outdoor coat when "smoking jacket" or "dressing gown" might be meant, though this one is a minor stylistic choice) need correction.
* Syntax and Word Choice: The narration often includes awkward phrasing. For example:
* "It figured that he was happy." (A bit of an outdated colloquialism; perhaps "It was typical that he was happy.")
* "The door moved past its mooring..." (A ship is moored; here, the door "ripped open," or it "came loose from its frame/hinges.")
* "My feet were nowhere near the stairs that were there; I hung three feet below it." (Confusing image; perhaps "I hung three feet below the threshold.")
* "his lounge coat's middle was also blood stained." (His waist or abdomen of the lounge coat was stained.)
2. Refine Sensory Descriptions for Flow
While the descriptions are vivid, some sentences feel overloaded with detail, creating a choppy read.
* Dialogue Tags: Be consistent with dialogue tags and use "said" to keep the focus on the dialogue. For example, "He said,” Look at it. The body right there!” he pointed at it." could be smoothed.
* Combine and Clarify:
* Example: "The barbs cut into his chest and groin. The barbs were covered in blood that dried there from his body, having flowed down to the masonry work there." → "The barbs cut deeply into his chest and groin, covered in dried blood that had flowed down onto the masonry work."
* Example: "It looked as if she struggled before the dagger sank into her flesh, and blood blossomed out of her chest cavity and ran between the valley of her breasts." → "It looked as though she had struggled before the dagger sank into her flesh, and blood blossomed from her chest cavity, running down into the valley between her breasts."
3. Strengthen the Ending
The final scene, where the seven bodies vanish and the house is consumed by fire, is a powerful moment of cosmic horror. However, the dialogue with the coroner, Frederick, is slightly repetitive and slow in conveying this crucial detail.
* Frederick's Role: He is skeptical, which is fine, but the back-and-forth about "seven bodies" versus "six bodies" and "went somewhere" drags slightly. Tighten this exchange to heighten the narrator's frantic state and the coroner's disbelief.
* Clarify the Fire: The house is described as "flame-ravaged" and having "soot-covered doors" before the bodies are found, suggesting an older, sustained fire damage. Then, at the very end, the narrator sees "its light as it continued to consume the house," suggesting the fire reignited or intensified upon the creatures' departure/the bodies' dissolution. This needs to be clearer. If the house was always burning, emphasize that; if the supernatural event caused it to burst into full flame, make that moment more dramatic.
The fundamental story—a classic Innsmouth mystery leading to a horrific, otherworldly sacrifice—is compelling and well-conceived. Focusing on the technical mechanics of the writing will allow the story's powerful imagery and atmosphere to shine unimpeded...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
11
11
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Redtowrite

This is a fascinating and emotionally layered story! Here is a detailed review of "Love Remains as Long as we Believe".
💖 Detailed Story Review: Love Remains as Long as we Believe
📝 Overall Impression and Strengths
This is a moving, poignant, and highly imaginative piece that successfully blends romance, mystery, and a touch of the supernatural. The story grips the reader from the start with the beautiful, immediate connection between Dan Huckley and Lindsey Mills.
The author excels at creating vivid, sensual descriptions, particularly of the characters themselves, Lindsey's unique art, and their idyllic honeymoon. The story's central emotional arc—the overwhelming joy of their love followed by the sudden, heartbreaking tragedy of Lindsey's disappearance—is handled with compelling and raw emotion, making Dan’s ensuing spiral and eventual, cryptic recovery deeply impactful.
The ending is superb, offering a mystical, satisfying, and poetic resolution that suggests love truly transcends the mortal world and ties back beautifully to Lindsey's original artistic process.
✨ Key Strengths in Detail
* Character Chemistry and Dialogue: The initial meeting between Dan and Lindsey is electric. Their dialogue is witty, engaging, and instantly establishes their personalities and the natural synergy between them. Lindsey, with her "sweet melodic quality" and "pixie like quality," is a captivating heroine, and Dan is a charming, appreciative counterpart.
* Unique Story Elements (The Art & The Bet): Lindsey’s artistic process—the creation of custom, personality-driven pieces—is wonderfully original and a great metaphor for the unique, tailored relationship she and Dan build. Their "virginity bet" adds a fun, frustrating, and endearing tension to their dating period, highlighting their deep, non-sexual connection first.
* Sensory and Emotional Detail: The author makes excellent use of sensory language. Descriptions like Lindsey’s laughter "like bells," her eyes with "a speckling of gold dust," and the "tropical paradise" of their wedding create an immersive experience. The pain of Dan’s loss, where he feels like he’s "walking through a fog," is visceral and well-portrayed.
* Thematic Resolution: The final reveal—that the stunning illustrations for Dan’s children’s book bear the initials L. M. H. and are guided by an "invisible artist whispering to him"—provides a deeply romantic and thematic closure. It suggests that Lindsey is fulfilling her purpose as an artist/creator, even in death, and that her love and essence truly remain.
🚧 Tips for Improvement
* Pacing in the Middle Section: The transition from the honeymoon to their life in New York/Jamaica feels a bit abrupt. While the author notes their life was an "adventure that lasted eighteen months," the shift to Lindsey's intense work schedule and Dan's inability to sleep without her could benefit from a few more scenes to illustrate the growing (though minor) marital friction before the pregnancy. This would slightly ground the "fairy tale" in more realistic complexity, making the final tragedy even more heartbreaking.
* The Mystery of the Disappearance: While the mysterious nature of her vanishing is key to the supernatural ending, the police investigation phase feels a bit rushed after Dan's initial shock. A little more internal reflection from Dan during the police questioning, or a single scene with Royce discussing the police's suspicions of Dan, could intensify the suspense and external pressure on the main character before he descends into his grief.
* Ulrike's Departure: The maid's fear of witchcraft/spirits and her subsequent quitting is a fantastic plot device to introduce the supernatural elements. The moment where Dan shakes her, demanding, "If she is a demon, I want her here," is a powerful, gut-wrenching line, but the lead-up to her finding the makeup being used and soiled tissues could be slightly more drawn out to build the atmospheric tension before her breakdown.
⭐ Final Assessment
"Love Remains as Long as we Believe" is a beautiful exploration of eternal love and the power of connection. It's a highly enjoyable read that delivers a powerful emotional punch and a memorable, perfectly earned mystical ending. The characters are vibrant, the love story is enchanting, and the mystery is resolved in a way that aligns perfectly with the romantic spirit of the entire narrative.
Would you like to explore other stories by this author or perhaps find out more about the themes of love and mystery in fiction?
That's a great question! Based on your story's blend of passionate romance, unexplained mystery, and a touch of the supernatural, you might enjoy diving deeper into similar themes.
Since you enjoyed "Love Remains as Long as we Believe" by Kathie Stehr, here are two paths you could explore:
1️⃣ Discover More from the Genre: Romantic Mystery
The genre that perfectly fits your story is Romantic Mystery or Paranormal Romance/Suspense, where the relationship is central, but a dangerous or unexplained element drives the plot.
* For Classic Mystery with Romantic Suspense:
* Mary Roberts Rinehart: Often referred to as the "American Agatha Christie," her work frequently blends suspenseful mystery with romantic elements, sometimes with a touch of the uncanny, as mentioned in the search results.
* Daphne du Maurier: Her short story "Kiss Me Again, Stranger" (mentioned in the search results) is a great example of an author who can keep the reader guessing, blending romance with a dark, unsettling quality.
* For Modern Paranormal/Suspense Authors:
* Nora Roberts (and her alter-ego J.D. Robb): Nora Roberts is a master of blending deep romance with suspense and mystery, often including subtle paranormal or mystical elements in her regular books...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
12
12
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Redtowrite

✍️ Detailed Review: The Trump Show, No Mask Needed
This piece, "The Trump Show, No Mask Needed", is a striking work of political satire that effectively uses poetry to critique a specific political figure and the surrounding atmosphere. The poem is clearly intended to provoke thought and convey a strong critical viewpoint.
Overall Impression
The poem is powerful, direct, and unapologetic in its satirical take on Donald Trump's presidency and rhetoric. It succeeds in establishing a dark, almost dystopian tone from the very first stanza, using vivid and deliberately harsh imagery. The central metaphor of the "orange clown" and the "circus" is immediately established and maintained throughout, creating a consistent and unsettling framework for the commentary.
The author uses an effective technique of adopting the perceived voice and defense of Trump and his supporters, only to swiftly undercut it with critiques. This duality makes the satire sharp and often uncomfortable, which is likely the author's intent. The ending, particularly the final stanza, provides a very clear and blunt summary of the piece's thesis.
Tips for Improvement
1. Refining Rhythm and Meter
* Consistency: The poem often switches between strong, rhyming couplets and lines that are less consistent in their rhythm and syllable count. While the AABB rhyme scheme is generally followed, smoothing out the meter would enhance the overall musicality and impact of the poem. For example, some lines feel noticeably longer or shorter than their counterparts, causing a slight stutter in the reading flow.
* Example: Compare the smooth flow of the first stanza's couplets with the third stanza's first line: "Rallied a crowd in Oklahoma, blamed China for the “kung Flu”." The line is very long, making the rhythm feel heavy compared to "Crowds close in to cheer, believing he truly cares."
2. Elevating Figurative Language
* Vary Imagery: The initial imagery ("orange clowns," "king with no clothes") is strong, but some later stanzas rely more on direct, journalistic-style references (e.g., "angry tweets," "kung Flu," "Radical democrats"). To make the satire even more biting and poetic, consider using more abstract or metaphorical language when discussing these topics. This could help turn reportage into lasting imagery.
* Suggestion: Instead of saying "explains bad things as a 'hoax'," perhaps a metaphor related to a magician's misdirection or a cracked lens on reality could be used, keeping the critique but elevating the language.
3. Pacing the Argument
* Clarity of Intent: The poem successfully uses irony when presenting Trump's alleged "positive" qualities ("Trump is handsome and smart," "he has a big heart"). However, in stanzas four and five, the shift from irony back to criticism (e.g., "Trump will leave America cold and stark") can feel a bit sudden. A slightly smoother transition, perhaps through a more subtle turn in the stanza, could help the reader follow the rapid shifts between the persona's voice and the author's voice.
Conclusion
"The Trump Show, No Mask Needed" is a bold and effective piece of political commentary. The author demonstrates a strong command of rhyme and a clear, unwavering perspective. The poem’s greatest strength lies in its unrelenting satirical voice and the successful establishment of a central, critical metaphor. The improvements suggested focus mainly on technical refinement of meter and adding layers to the already powerful imagery, which would allow the poem's message to land with even greater poetic force.
Would you like me to focus on a specific stanza and offer a line-by-line critique to help with the suggested rhythm adjustments?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
13
13
Review of Boss Hog Family  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hi
Jimmy E. Durham, RN-BC

That was quite the entertaining and exasperating read! The story, "Boss Hog Family," is a darkly comedic character sketch built around the protagonist, Seth's, obligation to his grandmother and the encounter with his cousin, Starr.
Here is a detailed review, focusing on honest feedback and tips for improvement.
✍️ Detailed Review: Boss Hog Family
Overall Impression
The story is hilarious and wonderfully cringe-worthy. It successfully nails the tone of satire and dark comedy, making Seth's internal monologue and interactions the clear focus. The writing is engaging and moves quickly, keeping the reader invested in Seth's attempts to navigate the chaos of his family. The descriptions of the "Boss Hog Family" are vivid and immediately set a distinct, almost cartoonish, picture in the reader's mind, effectively delivering on the promise of the title.
Key Strengths
* Character Voice: Seth's voice is the absolute strongest element. His dry wit, sarcasm, and deeply cynical internal monologue are consistent and entertaining. Lines like, "I had had a cat just like her. She got really fat, and then after some time she had babies. My mom and dad then took her and the babies to live on a farm where they could play with other cats and have as many babies as they wanted - not draining the American welfare system dry," are pitch-perfect for his character.
* Dialogue: The dialogue is sharp, realistic, and funny, especially the exchanges with Grandma and Starr. The verbal sparring with Starr over the smoking advice and "Earnestine" is the comedic peak of the story. It perfectly captures the frustrating absurdity of arguing with someone who is willfully ignorant.
* Pacing and Structure: The story is structured around a simple errand (driving Grandma to the doctor), which provides a natural arc for the conflicts (Grandma's demands, Starr's intrusion) to unfold. The pacing feels quick, even with the internal musings.
* Vivid Imagery: Starr's description is fantastic: "sunken in eyes complete with dark circles around them lent her the look of a malnourished raccoon." The image of her later "plopped off the sidewalk into the shrubbery; a kicking pair of cowboy boots was all that was visible" is a memorable, comedic final image.
Tips for Improvement
* Early Exposition and Focus: The opening paragraph starts with a slightly meandering internal reflection on Zen focus and life's purpose. While it establishes Seth's general lack of motivation, it feels a little disconnected from the strong, character-driven narrative that follows. You could trim this slightly to get to the conflict (the phone call) sooner.
* Tip: Consider replacing or shortening the "Zen focus" part with a line or two that immediately grounds us in his exhaustion and disdain for the day's upcoming chore.
* Clarity on Purpose/Plot: The story functions brilliantly as a slice-of-life/character study, but if there's a larger narrative goal (beyond just surviving the day), it's not clear. This isn't strictly necessary for a comedy piece, but a subtle thread of Seth contemplating a major life choice (perhaps related to escaping this family burden) could add weight.
* Show, Don't Tell (Minimal Instances): While most of the description is great, a few lines tell us things that could be slightly more impactful if shown. For example, "A task we all dreaded because it could only be described as something akin to going to visit with Boss Hog and the gang" is a great summary, but the reader has to wait until the Starr scene to really feel the dread. You might sprinkle a little more "Boss Hog" flavor into the interactions with Grandma earlier to sustain that atmosphere.
* Dialogue Tags/Action Beats: You handle dialogue well, but during the lengthy phone call with Grandma, it might help to break up the paragraphs with more action beats (physical things Seth is doing) instead of just summarizing her "prattling." You do this well later ("I set the receiver down and calculated the benefits...")—just a suggestion to use more of these to interrupt the flow of the conversation.

​🌟 Areas to Explore Further
​Deeper Dive into Character: We could analyze Grandma's role as the matriarch and the subtle power she wields, or examine the complex mix of cynicism and obligation that drives Seth.
​Thematic Analysis: We could discuss the story's successful handling of social class satire (the tension between Seth's education/profession and the "Boss Hog Family's" dependence on government aid).
​Craft Focus: We could look closely at comedic timing in the story, such as the setup and punchline of Starr's "Earnestine" moment, or how the physical comedy (Starr falling in the shrubbery) is used.

Conclusion
"Boss Hog Family" is a highly successful comedic piece that is ready for an audience. Seth is a compelling, hilarious protagonist who manages to be both the sarcastic observer and an integral, frustrated part of the drama. The story is a laugh-out-loud commentary on family obligation, entitlement, and willful ignorance, with the character of Starr serving as a perfect comedic foil.
Your writing is clear, punchy, and engaging. Great work!

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
14
14
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
drifter

Story Critique: Willing and able to Fight
Overall Impression:
This piece is a raw, passionate, and ultimately inspiring memoir detailing the author’s long struggle with mental illness, institutionalization, and the painful breakdown of a marriage. It is a powerful testament to resilience, faith, and the determined fight for self-definition against stigmatizing labels. The author successfully conveys the sense of isolation, confusion, and despair within the state hospital system and the subsequent betrayal and pain experienced during divorce. The story's greatest strength is its unvarnished emotional honesty and clear resolution to "fight."
Rating: 4.0/5 – Emotionally powerful and deeply honest; narrative structure could be tightened for clarity and focus.
Strengths 💪
Emotional Honesty and Central Theme
The author’s voice is brave and direct. The central theme of "Willing and able to Fight"—and the concept of "Witness to Withness"—is compelling, serving as a powerful rejection of the "crazy" label. The narrative effectively conveys the trauma of being hospitalized against one's will and the deep sense of shame, guilt, and abandonment that followed.
Vivid and Affecting Vignettes
The details from the Taunton State Hospital in the 70s are particularly strong and memorable:
* The initial shock of the naked woman and the quick assumption of the "resident crazy person" label.
* The isolation of having phone calls denied and feeling distant from family.
* The heartbreaking complexity of his relationships with Jerry Proffit (ending in tragedy) and the delusional man he sees as "Jesus" (Bill Barrett), which provided a perverse kind of spiritual comfort.
* The small, human moments of grace, like his father’s regular visits and the simple offering of a hamburger and pop.
Powerful Arc of Recovery
The two major crises (institutionalization in the 70s and the subsequent hospitalization during the divorce in the 2000s) provide a powerful, if painful, arc. The final paragraphs showcasing his forgiveness of his ex-wife, his consistent work history, and his commitment to therapy and accountability powerfully reinforce the theme of fighting for God's best.
Areas for Development 📝
Clarity and Narrative Structure
The story is structured chronologically within sections, but the major time jumps (from the 70s hospitalization to the divorce/second hospitalization in the 2000s) occur suddenly, which can momentarily disorient the reader.
* Suggestion: Use clearer section breaks or headings to delineate the two major life crises (e.g., "The Taunton Years: 1970s" and "Betrayal and Second Crisis: The 2000s").
Focus on the "Why" in Early Anxiety
The text references an anxiety that kept getting worse and regrets about a woman at college ("Sue"). While these feelings led to his initial hospitalization, the reader only gets glimpses of the stressor.
* Suggestion: Briefly clarifying the nature of the anxiety or the specific regret (without adding excessive detail) could ground the initial frantic actions and help the reader fully empathize with the intense fear of "not going to be okay."
Stylistic Refinement
The writing is very immediate and stream-of-consciousness, which contributes to the feeling of raw emotion. However, some long, complex sentences and occasional repetition could be tightened for readability.
* Suggestion: Focus on clear sentence structure, particularly when discussing complex emotional dynamics or legal/medical situations.
Final Thoughts ✅
This story is a crucial act of reclaiming one's narrative and should be commended for its courage. It is an honest examination of the systemic failures of mental healthcare and the deep interpersonal wounds that accompany mental health crises. The author's determination to rise above the chaos and choose life, love, and forgiveness is genuinely moving.
Do you plan to continue developing this memoir, perhaps by focusing more on the themes of forgiveness and rebuilding in your new life?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
15
15
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi
Redtowrite

Story Critique: Nursing is both Roses and Thorns
Overall Impression:
This is a deeply moving and tender tribute to the relationship between a compassionate nurse (Gwen) and her young terminal patient (Pam). The story excels in capturing the emotional intimacy that can form in the hospital setting, making Pam’s struggle with cancer feel heartbreakingly real and personal. The narrative is structured as a series of poignant vignettes across a year, culminating in a beautiful and peaceful final scene. The piece is rich with genuine empathy and emotional honesty.
Rating: 4.5/5 – A heartfelt and moving depiction of compassion, loss, and the humanity of nursing; could benefit from minor stylistic tightening.
Strengths 💪
Emotional Authenticity and Compassion
The central strength of this story is its unflinching yet gentle honesty about terminal illness. The narrator, Gwen, embodies true nursing compassion, respecting Pam's dignity and acknowledging her pain, both physical and emotional. The details—from Pam's refusal of the wheelchair to the conversation about the children and the "keep smiling" pressure from her husband—feel incredibly authentic to the patient experience.
Vivid Characterization
Pam is drawn as a fully realized, tragic figure: a young mother, a kindergarten teacher, whose sweetness is being consumed by the disease. Her nickname for cancer, the "Kudzu Monster," is a brilliant, metaphorically rich detail. The portrayal of her truly heroic resilience is moving. The narrator, Gwen, also shines as a thoughtful, empathetic professional struggling with the boundaries of her role.
Pacing and Structure
The decision to frame the narrative across "a year" of admissions effectively charts Pam's decline, allowing the reader to feel the weight of time and the accumulating loss. The final scene—the "glow" under the door, the silent pump, Pam's ethereal look, and the rare Atlanta snowfall—is a perfect, powerful culmination of the emotional journey.
Powerful Imagery
The story uses simple, effective imagery:
* The quilt made by cancer survivors symbolizes collective love and hope.
* Pam's fragile appearance, with tufts of blonde hair and visible tiny blue veins on her scalp, is heartbreakingly vulnerable.
* The final metaphor, "a perfect chantilly snowflake," provides a beautiful, peaceful resolution to her suffering.
Areas for Development 📝
Narrative Voice and Clarity
The transition between the nurse's reflections and the descriptive vignettes is occasionally abrupt, which slightly pulls the reader out of the moment.
* Suggestion: Some sections, like the initial meeting and the general description of her illness, could be slightly smoother. For example, a clearer demarcation could be helpful when the narrator is speaking as the nurse vs. reflecting on the personal connection (e.g., the Bob Dylan lyric feels a little detached from the immediate emotional flow).
Dialogue Punctuation
For greater professional polish, ensure consistent use of quotation marks and internal punctuation in the dialogue tags, particularly in the opening kitchen scene. While the meaning is always clear, standardizing dialogue formatting would elevate the reading experience.
Showing vs. Telling
The narrator states, "Ted won't tolerate depressing talk. Keep smiling!" This is a powerful conflict point.
* Suggestion: While Ted is mostly seen as supportive, showing a brief, subtle interaction where his emotional exhaustion or denial manifests would make this specific conflict even more gut-wrenching, rather than just stating Pam's perception of his emotional rule.
Final Thoughts ✅
This is a deeply sincere and effective piece of writing that honors the often-unseen emotional labor of nursing and the profound bond between caregiver and patient. The quiet dignity of Pam's death, contrasted with the intensity of her year-long battle, leaves a lasting impression.
The story highlights the "thorns" of nursing (the pain, the loss, the emotional toll) alongside the "roses" (the meaningful connection and the opportunity for deep compassion).
What aspect of Gwen's experience would you like to explore further—perhaps the role of the staff, or how she coped with the loss of a patient she grew so close to?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
16
16
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
SpookySilverMoon

That's a fantastic, highly relatable, and very funny short piece! It reads exactly like a great story you'd hear someone tell at a party.
Detailed Review: Mourning a Ruined Sweater
Overall Impression
This is a charming and successful anecdotal piece. You capture a perfect moment of accidental, expensive stupidity and turn it into great storytelling. The pacing is quick, the setup (the desperate need for a dry sweater) is clear, and the payoff (the shrunken sweater fitting the dog) is hilarious. The narrative voice is honest, self-deprecating, and highly engaging, which makes the whole situation instantly relatable.
Strengths
* Authentic Voice and Tone: The voice is the strongest part of the piece. Phrases like, "I'm almost embarrassed to share the details," and the internal monologue ("Oh great, I thought") make the narrator feel like a close friend confessing a silly mistake. This honesty is what makes the humor land so well.
* Excellent Humor/Climax: The punchline is brilliantly executed. The moment where you hold up the impossibly shrunken sweater and look down at your short-legged Yorkie, Little Bear, is the perfect comedic climax. The sister's subsequent, near-choking laughter confirms the comedic success of the scene.
* Sensory Hook: You start very effectively by immediately establishing the value of the object: "powdery gray color and pearl buttons," "soft to the touch." This makes the resulting destruction feel more consequential (and funnier!).
* Relatable Stakes: The setup—being far from home, needing the sweater immediately in cold weather, and lacking a dryer—creates immediate, low-stakes tension that justifies the desperate, "brilliant" microwave idea.
Tips for Improvement
While the story is already very strong, here are a few suggestions to make the climax and pacing even sharper:
* Enhance the Physical Description of the Ruin: You describe the original sweater beautifully, but the ruined one could use a little more vivid detail. Instead of just saying the "sleeves looked funny" and the body was "smaller," try using more visceral sensory language to describe the texture of the ruined angora. Was it stiff? Felted? Did it smell faintly of coffee and steam?
* Example revision: "I took it out and laid it on the counter. It felt strangely stiff, like thick cardboard that had been starched, and the powdery gray was now a dense, shrunken mass. The sleeves were comical, not just shorter, but fused, the arm holes tiny and hard..."
* Tighten the Middle Section: The monitoring process is important for establishing the narrator's focused effort, but the passage describing multiple checks ("After several times, I checked the sweater again. It felt dry, but steaming hot...") slows down the pace slightly. You could condense the attempts to keep the momentum driving toward the reveal.
* Example revision: Combine the action and the passing of time into one sentence: "I monitored it, taking it out every few minutes, but after what felt like a dozen cycles—my sister and I chatting away while Little Bear watched—it finally felt dry, if steaming hot."
* Strengthen the Final Reflection: The very last sentence, while accurate, is a bit of a simple wrap-up. You could end the piece on the strong visual image of the little sweater (perhaps contrasting it with Little Bear again) to let the humor linger a moment longer.
This is a great piece of writing—you have a confident, conversational style that really makes the reader feel like they're sitting in your sister's kitchen.
Let me know if you'd like to dive deeper on vividly describing the physical state of the ruined sweater or if you want to work on tightening the pacing in the middle section!

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
17
17
Review of Apartment 15  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi
Christopher Robin


This is a detailed review of the story fragment titled "Apartment 15".
👻 Overall Impression
"Apartment 15" is a highly effective, classic ghost story built on the theme of a rational mind being confronted by undeniable supernatural evidence. The story excels at establishing the narrator's rigid, scientific worldview, making his ultimate terror and retreat all the more powerful. The central phone call is masterfully executed, building slow, unsettling tension that culminates in the paramedic's chilling revelation. It's a taut, psychologically driven piece that explores the profound trauma of having one's foundational beliefs shattered.
🎙️ Character and Voice
Josh Meacham (The Narrator)
* Strong Opening Voice: The opening paragraphs, where Josh proudly proclaims himself a "rational man," a "child of reason," and a "proud and confident atheist," immediately establish the central conflict. His academic pursuit (PhD in Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy) reinforces his deep commitment to logic.
* Relatability in the Mundane: His reason for taking the job—needing money to finance his thesis—is entirely practical and relatable, grounding the story in reality before the horror begins. His annoyance at losing his thought process to the guilt of a potential emergency is a great touch of selfish realism.
* The Breakdown: The ending is the payoff. His frantic repetition of his mantras ("I am a rational man. I am a man of science. Nature cannot transcend itself.") and his quitting the job to stack shelves—a completely different, simple task—demonstrate the utter devastation of his mental framework. He is a man broken by an event that refuses to fit into his ordered universe.
🔪 Plot, Pacing, and Tension
The Setup
* The slow build-up describing the mundane nature of the job (rousting a handyman, a man trying to use a phone as a remote) is excellent pacing. It normalizes the routine of the night shift, which then makes the call from Apartment 15 feel like a sudden, sharp deviation.
The Central Incident
* The dialogue of the call is the story's peak. Mrs. Graham's repetitive, vague, and increasingly unsettling responses ("I just don't feel very well," "My name is Rose Graham...") create a powerful sense of unease. Her final, abrupt line—"I have to go the bathroom now. I am going to put the phone down"—is unnerving because it is both a normal human need and a sudden, illogical end to the conversation.
* The Reveal: The introduction of Paramedic Amanda Ryan via the same phone line is a brilliant narrative device. The exchange of information is sharp and professional, which serves to make the final, devastating reveal ("She's been dead for at least 10 hours") even more impactful. The professional, medical certainty of rigor mortis and lividity is the ultimate, empirical blow to Josh's scientific belief system.
The Conclusion
* Josh's futile attempts to rationalize the event (hallucination, sleep deprivation) before checking the system log show his desperate struggle. The final image of him hastily re-burying the memory in his "hindbrain" is a strong psychological conclusion, indicating that he is living in a state of deliberate, painful denial.
💡 Tips for Improvement
* Exploit the Setting's Potential: The location, a sheltered housing estate, is a great backdrop for a ghost story involving the elderly. While the story focuses on the phone call, you could briefly hint at the atmosphere of the place before the call—perhaps a cold hallway, an unsettling silence, or a fleeting reflection in a security monitor—to subtly enhance the overall mood of isolation and morbidity.
* Slightly Polish Dialogue Tags: In the intense exchange with the paramedic, a few dialogue tags could be tightened. For instance, the use of "I...I just don't understand" as a full line is powerful, but a small opportunity exists to keep the pace clipping in the preceding lines.
* The Title: While the title "Apartment 15" is specific and accurate, a slightly more evocative title might draw the reader in more strongly, though its simplicity is also effective in a minimalist horror context.
🌟 Final Assessment
"Apartment 15" is a successful piece of short horror. It works because the horror isn't about jump scares; it's about the philosophical and psychological terror of confronting the impossible. The execution of the central event and the resulting psychological damage to the narrator are handled with skill and precision.
* Rating: 5/5 Stars. A clear, well-paced, and chilling story.
I thought the tension created purely through dialogue was exceptional. Would you be interested in exploring the narrative function of the telephone as a device in this story?


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
18
18
Review of The Great Un  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi

jeff

This is a detailed review of the story fragment titled "The Great Un".
🖋️ Overall Impression
"The Great Un" plunges the reader immediately into a bleak, evocative, and compelling post-apocalyptic world. The writing is strong, utilizing sensory details and a distinct, gritty voice to create a palpable atmosphere. The dual narrative structure, switching between the immediate journey of the Messenger and the remembered history of the Prophet, is an effective way to introduce both the immediate peril and the grand, mysterious scope of the setting. The introduction of the subterranean command center, HUD, adds a layer of technocratic mystery and immediate peril, hinting at the causes of this "waste." This fragment successfully establishes a high level of intrigue and promises a rich, complex narrative to come.
🌍 World-Building and Atmosphere
The story's greatest strength lies in its vivid and unsettling world-building.
* Setting: The "frozen, broken land, shadowless beneath a sunless sky" and the "thick bone cold air" immediately set a desolate, brutal tone. The imagery is often surreal—the "unearthly orange color" of the pine trees that reminds the Messenger of pumpkin pie is a fantastic, jarring detail that juxtaposes the former world with the current ruin.
* Creatures: The dark beast, Chub, is a memorable and original companion. Described as a "giant mutated beaver" with tusks, a shaggy body, and an oval dome shape at rest, it is wonderfully strange. The pine grubs and their terrifying death scream add a visceral, horrifying element to the daily struggle for survival.
* Tone: The story manages a brilliant balance between the grim reality (cold, hunger, poison, mutation) and moments of darkly humorous or poignant observation (the memory of pie, the casual description of poisoning the grubs, the ferryman Billy-Bob's lament). The opening song lyric, "I’ve been through the desert on a horse with no name," perfectly sets the mood of lonely wandering.
👥 Characters and Voice
The Messenger/Prophet
* He is an enigmatic and compelling protagonist. His dual titles (Prophet, Profit) suggest a history of grand influence and subsequent fall.
* The flashbacks reveal a man who was once a powerful orator, able to command an audience with a tale of madness, revelation, and transformation. The description of his time in the cavern—losing himself, being "unveiled to the ebony universe," and returning hairless and "sexless"—creates a powerful sense of mythic rebirth.
* His physical state (withered left hand, bare feet, hairless body, the "fades") speaks volumes about the hardships and perhaps the nature of the change. He is a scarred survivor, driven by an unknown mission ("Always East").
Billy-Bob the Boatman
* Billy-Bob serves as an excellent local foil to the grander narrative. He grounds the apocalypse in human fear and mundane survival. His wailed cries of "Moooooooon..." and his reliance on a flask and "local medicinal herb" make him instantly sympathetic and a little pathetic.
* He also introduces the geographical anchor points—the Clumby River, the slot canyons, and the terrifying scablands to the east—adding to the map of this broken world.
Sven and Harry (HUD)
* These characters provide a glimpse into the technological remnants of the old world. Their "Dull moments" (the fades) and their incompetence (Sven's obliviousness, Harry's drunken self-sedation) suggest that the architects of the disaster are now its pathetic, failing caretakers.
* The escalating number of blinking orange and red lights creates a superb sense of foreboding, linking the man on the surface ("Forty-Two") to a potentially catastrophic event below ground.
⚙️ Tips for Improvement
* Clarify the Transition between Narratives: While the switch between the Messenger/Chub and the Prophet's flashback is effective, the third section, HUD, feels a bit abrupt. Consider adding a small transition thought from the Messenger as he falls asleep (e.g., a momentary thought about "the men who watch") or a very brief scene break before jumping to Sven and Harry to smooth the shift between the three separate storylines.
* Pacing the Prophet's Story: The description of the Prophet's fall and time in the Eye is richly poetic, but the interruption by the character Buddy, while serving to emphasize the Prophet's unusual state, breaks the flow of the revelation. This is fine, but the segment ends on an anticlimax ("The simplest of questions... Memories were mixed and muddled, or gone"). While the mystery is appreciated, a stronger immediate hook for the audience's reaction, or a more definitive purpose given for his journey, could make the flashback more impactful.
* Harnessing the Mystery of "The Great Un": The title is intriguing, but the nature of the "change" is only hinted at (minds lost in dream mists, the sickness of the land). As the story progresses, maintain the mystery but ensure the reader has enough breadcrumbs to form a hypothesis.
✨ Final Assessment
This is an excellent, high-concept piece of science fiction/fantasy. It immediately grabs the reader with its strong voice, unique world-building, and intriguing mysteries. The characters are compelling, and the threat feels immediate and multifaceted. The author has built a solid foundation for an epic journey across a ruined, mythic landscape.
* Rating: 5/5 Stars (for a fragment) - The execution of atmosphere, character, and suspense is top-tier.
Would you like me to focus on a specific aspect of the story, such as the symbolism or the narrative structure?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
19
19
Review of Into the Ruin  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

This story, "Into the Ruin," is a well-paced, action-focused chapter of what seems to be a classic fantasy-adventure tale. You've established a clear sense of place and have a diverse, interesting group of characters. All your story has the X factor that keeps me glue to them.
Overall Impression and Strengths
The chapter shines in its action sequences and pacing. The flow from sneaking, to a tense observation, to the chaotic fight with the spider and the skeletons, is excellent.
* Pacing: The story moves quickly without feeling rushed. You successfully interweave stealth, combat, and puzzle-solving (or, at least, clue-solving) into a single, cohesive narrative.
* Character Dynamics: The teamwork feels genuine. Skrie's role as the stealthy scout and healer, Malusk as the front-line tank, and Theren and Garrick as ranged/support fighters are all clearly defined and utilized effectively during the fights. Skrie's double-tap of healing on Malusk shows her immediate value.
* Worldbuilding through Clues: The final scene with the sarcophagus and the tiles is a great transition to the next part of the adventure. Theren's quick deduction, followed by the characters' individual reactions and knowledge (Malusk's story of Gurat and Skrie's comment on Jerol Almstead), efficiently layers in some history and culture of your world.
Tips for Improvement
While the action is strong, a few areas could be polished to give the story a richer texture.
1. Increase Sensory Detail
The strongest sense used is sight (darkness, dim light, green ooze), but you could deepen the reader's immersion by using the other senses, especially during the tense or dramatic moments.
* The Smell of the Temple: What does a "ruin" and a cultist temple smell like? Dust? Incense? Mold? The "hideous stench" after the spider is a great moment—lean into that kind of sensory detail earlier.
* The Sound of Stealth: When Skrie is sneaking, describe the sound of their soft footfalls on the "brown rock tiles." When she's straining to hear the cultists, you could describe the low, muffled sound of their voices as a faint "grumble" or "hiss."
* The Feeling of Combat: When the green ooze hits Malusk's shield, you say it nearly ripped the shield from his arm. You could describe the physical strain Malusk feels: "...wrenching the shield from the webbing, the sticky force nearly tearing his shoulder from its socket."
2. Clarify Movement and Positioning
In a few places, the specific location of the characters or creatures can get a bit confusing, which slightly pulls the reader out of the action.
* The Cultist: Skrie spots a cultist, signals her friends, and they hide. When they sneak back in, the scene shifts to the rooms to the north. But then, later, they see another cultist hiding in the eastern doorway. It could be clearer if this second cultist is the same one who entered and left the hero's room, or if they are a completely new threat.
* The Spider's Entrance: When the spider returns, the line, "Hearing a noise behind her, Skrie glanced back to see the spider entering the room..." is good, but it might be worth reminding the reader exactly which doorway it's entering through (the one it was stuck in, or another entrance).
3. Dialogue Tags and Variety
Most of the dialogue is tagged with a variation of "said" (e.g., "said the halfling," "Garrick responded," "Malusk, looking at the third plaque,") which is fine, but you have great opportunities to show emotion or action through the tags, especially given the tension.
* Example: Instead of, "Now what?' asked Theren." you could try: "'Now what?' Theren whispered, wiping sweat from his brow." or "'I'll take a peek,' the halfling muttered, already slipping through the doorway." Use action instead of a tag to add immediate context.
Specific Feedback on Character & Plot
| Character/Plot Point | Observation | Suggestion |
|---|---|---|
| Skrie's Scouting | She's very effective and is clearly the stealth expert. | When she returns, consider adding a brief physical detail about why the hidden cultist got away (e.g., she spots a scratch mark on the wall or a hidden release for a stone, suggesting a secret passage). |
| The Cultist Messenger | The cryptic line, "... longer ... thought." is good for mystery. | Consider having a character (like Theren) speculate on what "tower" they mean, tying the immediate scene to the greater plot/geography of your world. |
| The Spider Fight | Great action—it really pins down the tank. | Malusk is a half-orc, so his physical strength should be highlighted. Emphasize the sheer brute force it takes for him to rip himself free from the webs, making his effort feel monumental. |
Overall, this is a strong, compelling chapter that leaves the reader wanting to follow the team "Down the Rabbit Hole." The ending is a perfect cliffhanger!
Would you like me to focus on one of these areas, like expanding the sensory details or developing the character dialogue for the next chapter?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
20
20
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

This excerpt, "Down the Rabbit Hole," offers a solid, action-packed chapter from what appears to be a fantasy-adventure narrative, likely based on a role-playing game or a similar world.
🗡️ Overall Impression
The story is engaging and moves at a quick pace, driven by a series of immediate challenges and the party's pragmatic, resourceful reactions. The stakes feel real, particularly with the mentions of the cultists' persistence and the party's limited magical resources. The dialogue helps establish the characters, especially the difference between the more practical, aggressive Malusk and Skrie versus the more cautious Theren. The use of specific items like a barrel of Holy Water, lockpicks, and a silver-coated dagger adds flavor and grounding to the fantasy setting.
📜 Detailed Analysis
Plot and Pacing
The plot follows a clear sequence of events:
* Discovery and Entrapment: The party secures their position by sabotaging the collapsed stairs, effectively trapping themselves but also blocking pursuit. The discovery that the stairs were trapped is a nice detail, immediately establishing a dangerous environment.
* First Confrontation: They face a zombie and a cultist, which serves as a small-scale combat encounter that drains their resources ("cost most of their remaining magic reserves").
* The Counter-Trap: Hearing the cultists attempt to batter through their barricade, the party devises a brutally clever plan to use the lamp oil and the fallen debris as a powerful, ignited trap. This is a great moment of non-magical resourcefulness.
* Second Confrontation (Escalation): The battle with the first animated skeleton proves the threat is escalating, as this creature is "smarter" and "more sturdy" than the average undead, raising the tension for future encounters.
* New Clues and Progress: The discovery of the poisoned cultist's body and the new set of lockpicks gifted to Skrie provide new plot threads and useful items before the party finds the next stairway down.
The pacing is excellent for an action chapter, with one challenge quickly following another.
Characterization
The characters are defined mostly by their actions and a few lines of dialogue, which works well for a fast-paced chapter:
* Skrie (Cleric/Halfling/Scout): She is cunning and ruthless (devising the oil-fire trap), observant ("These were trapped," "Almonds... and sulfur"), and appreciative of practical gifts (the lockpicks).
* Malusk (Half-Orc): He is the brawn (jams the post, impales the zombie) and pragmatist (approving of Skrie's trap, commenting on the failure of their "plans"). His speech pattern—using words like "gonna," "ain't," and "t' do"—gives him a distinct, rougher voice.
* Theren (Mage/Elf): He serves as the moral compass (shocked by the fire trap) and the knowledge source (explaining sulfur). He is shown to be physically and magically strained by the fighting.
* Garrick: He is the steady, supportive fighter (identifying the trap, giving Skrie his lockpicks) and provides the grim motivation for the fire trap by mentioning the cultists shooting "Mayze in the back."
Writing and Dialogue
The writing is clear and functional, focusing on conveying the action directly. The dialogue is snappy and serves to move the plot or reveal character traits (e.g., Malusk's rough-hewn mannerisms).
The scene where Skrie receives the lockpicks is a nice moment of inter-party bonding and trust building:
> "here, you keep these." He handed her a set of lockpicks. "I have better ones, and I've seen you eyeing them. So, these are yours."
>
🌟 Tips for Improvement
* Sensory Detail: While the action is clear, more sensory detail could enhance the atmosphere. For example, describe the smell of the decay, the feel of the catacomb air, or the sight of the monstrous skeleton more vividly. The "almonds and sulfur" detail is a great start—apply that level of detail elsewhere.
* Emotional Weight: Theren's capitulation and Garrick's flat voice when mentioning Mayze are strong emotional beats. The story could linger on these moments slightly longer to increase the impact of the party's desperate situation and the moral cost of their actions.
Overall, this is a very strong, well-structured chapter that perfectly sets up the next conflict.
Would you like me to focus on a specific character's actions or predict what might happen in the next chapter, "Escape and Back Again"?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
21
21
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

This chapter, "Investigating the Cultists," is a tense and crucial moment of reconnaissance that successfully elevates the stakes of the entire mission. It transforms the vague threat of a cult into a specific, horrifying enemy profile: a group led by powerful necromancers operating with dangerously thin resources.
Overall Impression
The story effectively shifts the focus from rescue to strategic information gathering. The chapter’s success lies in its central reveal: the cult is using high-level necromancy to replenish its workforce. This information is vital, raising the stakes considerably while simultaneously revealing a potential weakness in the enemy’s deployment, creating a clear opportunity for the heroes to act.
Analysis and Strengths
The Horrific Revelation of Necromancy
The depiction of the cult’s ability to create undead minions is the highlight of the chapter.
* Visual Horror: The swirl of black mist and the dark red swirls of light and fire is a chilling and highly effective visual sequence. It conveys that the enemy is using forces far beyond simple banditry or standard cult rituals.
* Practical Threat: Theren’s analysis—that any mage who can instantly raise a body they just killed is "much more skilled"—is excellent exposition. It grounds the magical threat in a way that informs the party and the reader of the immense danger they face. Skrie’s immediate silent prayer to Tymora provides a genuine, human reaction to the sight.
* Resource Management: The realization that the cult is forced to use its prisoners to create new workers shows that the villagers' escape hurt the cult's labor pool.
Strategic Intelligence Gathering
The reconnaissance is highly productive, providing three key pieces of intelligence necessary for the next chapter:
* Confirmation of Pursuit: The overheard conversation in the black and gold robes ("search," "farms," and "kill") immediately validates the party’s decision to relocate the villagers to the distant farm in the previous chapter, reinforcing their strategic competence.
* Pinpointing the Target: The party deduces the necromancer and the mysterious figure are housed in the tower, making it the obvious primary objective for the coming infiltration.
* Identifying a Weakness: Malusk’s observation that the guards are "stretched real thin" due to sending out search parties is a brilliant tactical discovery. It turns the terrifying display of power (necromancy) into a calculated risk, as the party realizes the enemy’s primary force is now split and vulnerable.
Character Dynamics
The reactions of the party members are distinct and true to their established roles:
* Skrie: The religious anxiety ("Oh, gods," praying to Tymora) highlights the gravity of facing true dark magic.
* Malusk: His pragmatic nature comes through both in his grumbling ("I hates magics") and his crucial strategic observation about the guard patrols.
* Theren: He functions as the intellectual, calmly assessing the level of the magical threat rather than reacting emotionally.
Tips for Improvement
1. Linking the Threats (The Drow Elf)
The "tall, thin, hooded figure" responsible for the necromancy feels like a separate entity from the Drow elf revealed in the previous chapter.
Suggestion: To maintain continuity and maximize tension, subtly link the two figures. Perhaps Theren recognizes a faint silver-white strand of hair escaping the hood, or he mentions that the powerful necromancy is "precisely the kind of dark magic a Drow elf is infamous for." This would connect the previous information-gathering to the current, devastating discovery.
2. Dialogue Pacing and Realism
During the tense observation, the characters sometimes speak in overly complete sentences. For moments of high suspense and stealth, dialogue should be kept to absolute necessities.
* Example for Revision: Instead of: "Let's keep watching to see if they leave the tower," said Skrie. "I have a feeling that what we're looking for is in there."
* Consider: "Keep watching," Skrie whispered. "It's in the tower."
3. Strengthening the Foreshadowing
The chapter ends with Theren noting the skill of the necromancer. This is great, but the "Recovering the Relics" title suggests a specific objective.
Suggestion: Add a line during the observation phase to foreshadow the need for relics. For instance, after the necromancy, one of the heroes could note: "That much power... whatever they're after in those lower tombs must be giving them a massive boost." This would directly transition to the goal of the next chapter.
Conclusion
"Investigating the Cultists" is a strong preparatory chapter. It successfully introduces a terrifyingly skilled antagonist and provides the heroes with the strategic intelligence they need—the enemy is powerful, but distracted and geographically spread thin. The groundwork is now perfectly laid for the infiltration and direct confrontation in the next chapter, "Recovering the Relics."
The party knows what they are up against, where they need to go (the tower/lower tombs), and the optimal time to strike. What sort of specific defenses or traps do you have planned for the lower tombs to challenge their newfound tactical advantage?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
22
22
Review of Relocation  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae


This chapter, "Relocation," is a necessary and highly effective wrap-up to the rescue mission and a detailed setup for the next stage of the adventure. It focuses on logistics, information gathering, and separating the liabilities (villagers) from the assets (the heroes), ultimately preparing the party to directly engage the cult.
Overall Impression
"Relocation" is a well-paced, information-heavy chapter that skillfully manages the immediate aftermath of the previous night's action. It excels at establishing a temporary safe haven, demonstrating the practical skills of the party (foraging, hunting, healing), and extracting critical intelligence from the villagers. The chapter successfully introduces a major new threat (The Drow Elf) and a local hazard (The Valley of Irewick), greatly enriching the world and raising the stakes for the upcoming infiltration.
Analysis and Strengths
Logistic and World-Building Detail
The chapter takes time to focus on the practical realities of survival, which grounds the fantasy in realism:
* Teamwork: The division of labor—Skrie scouting and foraging for herbs, Malusk hunting, the villagers gathering resources—shows a cohesive, functional unit. This quiet, necessary work contrasts effectively with the previous action.
* The Safe Cave: The cave is quickly made into a viable, temporary camp, complete with a hot meal, which highlights the competence of the survivors and the heroes.
* The Valley of Irewick: The introduction of this haunted, war-torn valley as a geographical barrier is a great piece of local lore. It serves a practical purpose (explaining why few people go to the farm) while adding a layer of atmosphere and future threat.
Information Gathering and Revelation
The central purpose of the chapter is to glean information, and it delivers several crucial plot points:
* Cult Activities: The party learns that the cult was focused on the "lower tombs," confirming the existence of a hidden area and the key objective.
* External Conflict: The villagers mention a recent event—a fight or "screams"—in the tombs that seemed to prompt the guards to bring them out early, suggesting the cultists themselves are facing problems down below.
* The Drow Elf: The description of the "strange dark woman" with "tar-black skin and silver-white hair" and Theren's immediate identification of her as a potential Drow elf is a massive plot twist. This elevates the threat level, as Drow are typically powerful and dangerous antagonists with deep ties to the Underdark.
The New Alliance and Garrick's Test
The party strategically splits forces to maximize safety and efficiency:
* Military Link: Jorge and Jackson head to Fort Bridale, establishing the military link that was foreshadowed earlier.
* Securing the Civilians: The villagers' suggestion of the "odd, but nice enough" horcs' farm provides a realistic sanctuary far enough away.
* Garrick's Commitment: Garrick volunteering to accompany the villagers and soldiers is his first true act of loyalty and responsibility. Paired with his earlier test, his presence with the civilians and armed soldiers further solidifies his transition from captive to reluctant ally.
Tips for Improvement
1. Differentiating Villager Dialogue
In the scene where Skrie listens to the villagers talking about the events in the tombs, the dialogue sometimes blends together ("one man say," "said another," "said a halfling").
Suggestion: Use distinct voice or subject matter to differentiate speakers, or attribute the most important details to specific, named characters like Jamal or Mayze (e.g., Jamal confirmed the story: "I seen that strange dark woman carry a fancy box from the tombs.") This makes the crucial information easier to track.
2. Skrie's Knowledge of Drow
Skrie states, "The cleric wracked her brain for knowledge of Drow elves and came up with nothing. She had heard the word somewhere but knew nothing..." This contrasts somewhat with her established competence. In a typical fantasy setting, Drow are a major, fearsome concept.
Suggestion: Instead of knowing nothing, perhaps she only knows rumors—that they are evil, deadly, and rarely seen on the surface. This would maintain her experience while still underscoring the severity of the threat and Theren's superior academic knowledge.
3. Punctuation in Dialogue
The author frequently uses a comma followed by a conjunction where a full stop or a semicolon might be more grammatically accurate, giving the dialogue a slightly rambling feel.
* Example: "I been through there lots o' times and ain't seen none of that, but I stay out of the valley when I can." While this reflects a natural, spoken rhythm, occasionally using a period or breaking the sentence would improve readability.
This chapter successfully concludes the rescue arc and elevates the main quest with the introduction of high-level threats (Drow) and a complex environment. The stage is perfectly set for "Investigating the Cultists," where the heroes can finally move from defense to offense.
Do you have a clear idea of what kind of challenges the heroes will face when they return to the ruins to investigate the cultists' activities?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
23
23
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

This chapter, "Saving the Villagers," is a robust and satisfying fulfillment of the promise made in the previous installment. It masterfully combines elements of stealth, combat, and large-scale rescue, resulting in a successful operation that significantly changes the party's composition and dynamics.
Here is a detailed review of the story.
Overall Impression
This chapter is a high-stakes, high-reward success story that demonstrates the party's competence and resourcefulness. The mission is executed through careful planning and decisive action, moving the heroes from hiding to becoming leaders of a small, fortified community of survivors. The use of Garrick as a critical informant, the discovery of the hidden children, and the forging of new alliances (with the soldiers and villagers) are all strong plot points that propel the narrative toward the final confrontation at Nemeademore.
Analysis and Strengths
Strategy and Execution
The rescue is planned and executed with clear, logical steps, making the success believable:
* Reconnaissance: The group uses the high ground and Garrick's knowledge to pinpoint key locations (guard post, prisoner buildings, ruins).
* Neutralizing the Threat: The elimination of the hill guard and the cave guard are necessary steps that are handled efficiently.
* Key Discoveries: The discovery of the two surviving soldiers (Jorge and Jackson) and the drugged children completely re-frames the mission's scope from simple reconnaissance to a large-scale rescue.
* The Diversion: Theren’s idea to use the livestock as a diversion is clever, classic adventure storytelling that explains how Malusk and Skrie can penetrate the village perimeter undetected.
Character Development and Alliance Forging
The chapter excels at establishing new, necessary relationships:
* Garrick's Test: Skrie forcing Garrick to "put your money where your mouth is" by guarding the soldiers and children is a great way to test his loyalty without relying on easy trust. His sulking acceptance reinforces his self-serving nature while ensuring his compliance.
* The Soldiers: Jorge is immediately established as a reliable, grateful ally. He quickly volunteers for watch, signaling that the party has gained competent, armed reinforcement.
* Skrie's Leadership: Skrie's interactions with the villagers solidify her as the leader. Her confident use of the password ("In Janna's name") and her blunt challenge to the "belligerent chap" ("You don't [trust me], but if you want to take your chances...") are excellent examples of her pragmatic, no-nonsense leadership style. Her actions earn her the respect of the survivors.
Pacing and Structure
The story maintains a high level of tension throughout the rescue and then achieves a satisfying, if temporary, resolution. The final scene, where the newly rescued people are fed and offer to take watch, is a powerful moment of community and mutual aid, showing the immediate fruits of the heroes' labor. The transition to the next chapter, "Relocation," is logically set up by the realization that they can’t stay in the cave.
Tips for Improvement
1. Differentiating the Village Reconnaissance
The early part of the reconnaissance from the hill is a bit repetitive. The group watches a guard walk, then moves to another hill and watches more guards patrol, without a major discovery until dusk.
Suggestion: Use the "bonfire and conclave" as the single, major observation moment. Skrie could use the time before the conclave to discover the cave/soldiers, and the duration of the conclave to execute the rescue of the adults, making the two halves of the operation feel more simultaneous and urgent.
2. Enhancing Sensory Details of the Village
The description of the village is functional ("old tower, partially destroyed," "two tombs"), but doesn't convey the full feeling of an occupied, oppressed town.
Suggestion: Add details that suggest the cult's presence or the villagers' suffering. For example, the Bonfire could smell of acrid incense, or the Tower could be draped with a dark banner. When Skrie enters the homes, she could notice the stale air, the threadbare blankets, or the signs of previous abuse, which would heighten the emotional stakes of the rescue.
3. Garrick's Immediate Role
While testing Garrick is a good idea, his repeated whining and complaining about food in this chapter ("Trail mix?" "Can't we make a fire...") distracts from the high-tension environment.
Suggestion: Reduce the frequency of his complaints and focus more on his nervous energy. His whines could be replaced with actions—Garrick paced restlessly, his eyes darting to every shadow, his need for a hot meal clearly secondary to his fear of being caught by his former allies. This would still convey his annoying personality while keeping the tension high.
Conclusion
"Saving the Villagers" is a successful, engaging chapter that significantly develops the plot and the characters. Skrie, Malusk, and Theren prove their effectiveness as a team, and the introduction of new allies and complications (the drugged children, the lack of food) sets up a clear, immediate challenge for the next installment. The groundwork has been laid for a major confrontation with the cultists near the ruins...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
24
24
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

This chapter, "Saving the Prisoners," is the natural and action-packed continuation of the previous installment, successfully executing the rescue and transitioning the focus from reconnaissance to interrogation and planning.
Here is a detailed review of the story.
Overall Impression
"Saving the Prisoners" is a strong chapter that excels in pacing, character interaction, and essential plot development. The initial rescue is swift and satisfying, proving the competence of the heroes and establishing an alliance with the villagers. The second half, centered on the interrogation of the captive Garrick, is the true highlight. Garrick's anxious, overly talkative personality is a fantastic and humorous contrast to the stoic Malusk and the pragmatic Skrie, and his dialogue delivers a large amount of crucial world-building information in an engaging, if verbose, manner.
Analysis and Strengths
Action and Execution
The rescue plan is simple, clear, and efficient, which works well for a short action piece.
* Tactics: Skrie’s decision to free the Hinfolk first, banking on them becoming immediate allies ("reinforcements"), is a great strategic choice that pays off instantly.
* Pacing: The action sequence is over in moments, preventing it from dragging, and the result is a decisive victory.
* Emotional Beat: The young Hin’s grief ("They killed me pa!") and Skrie’s immediate, relatable anger ("I know how ya feel") is a powerful, brief moment that grounds the fight in personal tragedy and fuels their shared motivation.
Character of Garrick
The introduction of the captive, Garrick, is a major success. He is a richly drawn, unexpected character: a self-proclaimed, cynical mercenary who is out of his depth in the wilderness.
* Humor and Contrast: His constant, high-maintenance whining—begging for water, food, wine, and his possessions—provides needed comic relief after the heavy atmosphere of the previous chapter. His city-slicker complaints ("The woods, not me! You know there are things out there that will eat you?") contrast hilariously with the hardened heroes.
* Information Delivery: Despite his annoying nature, Garrick is an excellent exposition tool. Because he wants to talk, he delivers a wealth of information about the cult's methods, the presence of the old wizard, the burning of the village priest, and the location of the ruins, all in a believable, self-serving ramble.
Plot Development and World-Building
The chapter massively advances the central conflict:
* New Allies: Jorund gives them the vital password, "In Janna's name," creating an explicit link to the remaining villagers.
* New Antagonists: Garrick confirms the existence of the cult's leader figure, "The One," and the powerful, non-aligned wizard who is using them for his own treasure hunt. This adds depth to the villainous structure.
* The MacGuffin: The search is confirmed to be for "something special" in "old books," solidifying the reason for the cult's presence at the ruins.
Tips for Improvement
1. The Interrogation Scene (Focus vs. Length)
While Garrick’s dialogue is great, the repetition of his begging for water and food becomes slightly distracting and, at times, slows the forward momentum. His neediness is established early; subsequent requests could be shortened or replaced with more descriptive actions (e.g., He eyed Malusk’s dagger, then licked his dry lips again).
Suggestion: Keep the core of his personality, but edit a few lines to tighten the information flow without losing his character. For example, the lengthy exchange about the dry rag and repeated water requests could be reduced to emphasize his distraction:
* Garrick coughed and winced. "Wow, that rag... I need water. And some food, please? That thing tasted nasty. Look, I was hired to guard some priests..."
2. Differentiating the Captives
The story presents two main captives: the chanting fanatic and Garrick. The third and fourth cultists are only mentioned as being put under a sleep charm and bound. Giving the fanatic a specific, non-verbal action to contrast with Garrick's whining could make him a more potent threat.
* Instead of just "refusing to speak," show his silent, intense devotion. The armored man didn't move, his eyes fixed with manic intensity on Malusk, a thin line of spittle tracing the edge of his forced gag. This maintains his threat even while he's bound.
3. Skrie's Role as Interrogator
Skrie is established as the more intelligent and perceptive member, but she resorts to kicking Garrick to get him to talk. While effective, a character as sharp as Skrie might use psychological pressure rather than physical force, especially since Garrick is already terrified.
Suggestion: Use the threat of Malusk's silent presence or the potential return of the villagers to elicit information, which better aligns with her earlier intelligence. (e.g., "The villagers are hungry for justice, Garrick. Talk now, or I'll let them decide what 'justice' looks like.")
This is a very successful chapter that skillfully blends action and investigation. The introduction of Garrick is a brilliant way to deliver crucial information about the cult and the wizard while injecting personality and humor into the narrative. The party is now fully informed and positioned to take the next step.
The next chapter is titled "Saving the Villagers." Based on this, do you think the core group (Skrie, Malusk, and Theren) will try to go directly into Nemeademore, or will they first attempt to gather the scattered villagers for support?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
25
25
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with disABILITY WRITERS GROUP  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Just Jae

I see you're continuing the adventure! This chapter, "The Road to Nemeademore," functions perfectly as a classic adventure setup, transitioning the characters from safety to the immediate threat of their mission.
Here is a detailed review of the story.
Overall Impression
"The Road to Nemeademore" is a strong transitional chapter that executes the necessary logistics of travel while expertly building tension and setting the stage for conflict. The story is highly effective at establishing the reality of the quest, moving it from a passive objective (finding old tomes) to an urgent rescue mission. The party dynamics are clear and appealing, and the discovery of the dead soldiers and cultists introduces a great layer of immediate mystery and danger. It feels very much like a well-structured scene from a fantasy role-playing game.
Analysis and Strengths
Pacing and Structure
The story uses time markers ("candlemark," "half a league") effectively to pace the travel sequence. The narrative is structured logically:
* Setup/Travel: Establishes the group's objective and Skrie's initial caution.
* Discovery: Finds the first evidence of conflict (blood, bodies, the clue "2 live").
* Investigation/Clues: The characters correctly deduce the nature of the fight and gather items (sword, sigil).
* Escalation: Finds fresher tracks and deduces the presence of prisoners.
* Reconnaissance: Skrie's solo scouting mission provides crucial information and a clear objective for the next chapter.
This progression keeps the reader engaged, as every mile marker brings a new, more serious development.
Character Dynamics and Role Fulfillment
The relationship between the three main travelers is well-defined:
* Skrie: She is the cautious, perceptive leader. Her ability to spot subtle clues ("prints were distributed") and her deduction that some travelers are prisoners is a great moment of intelligence and experience. Her decision to scout alone shows her competence and the group's reliance on her stealth.
* Malusk: He is the loyal protector and the strong presence. His physical strength (carrying Skrie) and his concern for her safety ("Ya know I don' like when ya goes off on yer own") anchor him as the group’s foundation.
* Theren: He is the enthusiastic novice whose excitement contrasts nicely with Skrie's caution. His spontaneous decision to pocket the sigil and scabbard demonstrates his eagerness for magical artifacts and sets up a minor subplot.
Conflict and Mystery
The discovery of the bodies is handled very well. The detail of the soldier's uniform, the dark cultist robe, and the simple wooden cross sigil immediately creates questions about the factions involved. The blood-written clue, "2 live," is particularly chilling and effective, instantly raising the stakes and suggesting survivors need help.
Tips for Improvement
1. Enhancing the Cultist Dialogue (The Info Dump)
The final scene where Skrie overhears the cultists is highly informative, but the dialogue functions a bit too much as an exposition dump. The cultists essentially summarize the entire plot: their purpose ("work the ruins"), their boss ("The One"), their tactics ("hunting villagers"), and the main threat ("walking bones").
Suggestion: Make the conversation sound more natural and less like a news report. Let the reader infer the plot points through more colloquial complaints.
* Instead of: "The others are exploring the ruins, and we're stuck out here hunting villagers."
* Try: "I wish I was with Kellen down at the crypts instead of chasing scared peasants. At least Kellen gets to play with the bone-walkers." (Uses stronger, more evocative language.)
2. Deepening Emotional Reactions
Skrie states that she's worried about the task, but we don't feel that apprehension in her physical presence. Her internal state should manifest in visible ways.
* Example: When Geordo finishes talking about the undead, Skrie could be described as instinctively touching the sigil she wears, or her eyes might dart more quickly into the shadows. Show her nerves rather than just having her state, "I'm not sure this will be the easy task."
3. More Sensory Detail on the Old Road
The journey itself is crucial, but the description of the "old road" is currently very general ("overgrown," "not been traveled in years"). Since they spend a full day on it, bring the setting to life:
* Does the path crunch with dry leaves, or is it slick with moss?
* Do the forgotten cobblestones trip them?
* What is the specific smell of the ancient, untraveled woods? (Damp earth, pine, quiet decay?)
This would make the travel time feel more immersive and less like a necessary delay before the action.
I think this chapter is a great piece of quest development, and it sets up the next installment, "Saving the Prisoners," with high energy and a clear goal!
Do you want to focus on Skrie's plan to rescue the prisoners next, or perhaps explore the full details of the dead cultist's symbol?
Do let me know...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
1,063 Reviews • *Magnify*
Page of 43 • 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://webx1.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sindbad