It's a fascinating concept. I bought into the story from the beginning, and I would like to read more. You also did a great job of the ending.
The pace was fast, and the dialogue was interesting. In the end, I was not sure who was speaking, But that did not take away from my understanding.
I don't get the beginning, where the story started. But I get the struggle in the middle and the promise in the end. I love the phrase "began the drudgery of survival."
Overall, this is an enjoyable tale. It may be science fiction, but stories are about people, and your story is about relationships in hard times.
I like it. A good romance. You used the setting to reinforce the gentleness of their love. For the last sentence, I would eliminate the word 'right'. I had to read the last sentence twice. Good job, well written.
It is kind of morbid but well-written. I was on Writing.com several years ago and found most of the work was by new, not very experienced writers. It is nice to see it has become more professional.
Patty
I loved it, especially the end. Before the end, I had considered the same thought, so I was glad when Aurelius made that choice.
It had all the elements of a good tale. I don't know where you came up with the picture, but it is perfect.
It was very well written. I enjoyed the story from start to finish. I like the fantasy and the descriptions of how the girl felt. That is one advantage of first-person writing.
You write well. You describe a near-death experience. The ending needs more description. Maybe more about the pain returning or his continued confusion. Was he really alive again? Who was his Godfather?
How did he Die? He was curious during the DREAM; he would be curious after the dream. Since this is part two, the story continues. This is a good chance to do some foreshadowing.
Thank you for sharing this poem. I had a good laugh. Some of my children have a dreadful fear of spiders.
I like spiders, at least the ones that don't have poison. They eat a lot of bugs. Your poem shows both sides of spiders.
Your poem has a good cadence, and your choice of rhyming words is interesting.
I love Star Trek. So I find this interesting. I suspect you want this to be a tense scene. To accomplish that you might try leaving out some of the actions between the dialog. (too much swiveling)
You might consider opening with the dialog. "Navigator, what is our estimated time of arrival on Vulcan?" That sentence sets the scene without further narration.
You first sentence should be "My earliest exposure to spaceflight was at Space Camp.
Then talk about your experience at Space Camp. Tell about how you felt, about your excitement.
That is your 'HOOK'
Your teacher says tell more about it. But I think he would like to hear more about your personal journey, not just where you went and an itinerary of events.
When you speak of your parents support tell how grateful you were for it.
What did you do at the Planitarium? What did you see? What did you Learn? Give more details. Make your audience wish they were there.
You best paragrah was about the 'mission Pin' because you gave details about how you felt.
The other comment is to break up your talk into smaller paragraphs. You will find it easier to slow down and breath as you speak.
Its a beautiful poem. It has an interesting message.
I love the rhythm and cadence.
It's the kind of poem that impacts on a spiritual level.
I like the phrase "A carousel around the sun, Hurling through the vast abyss". It is a romantic way of describing this earth we live on.
Good job.
It was a good scene, but it was not a complete story. I am sitting here trying to figure out what it lacked.
Your descriptions of the Gunny and the students was good.
The story just did not seem complete. Like the end was missing something. I came away feeling flat.
I wish I could be of more help
I liked your use of flying to pull the story together.
Your first two paragraphs are a good set up. They show us a great deal about George's situation, without telling.
Your start is slow, because you have used so many irrelevant details.
Paragraph eight: "it all added up, she'd tell him." The word "no" should be added.
In section 1 you call the store Walmart. In section 2 you say: "it was the old Sur-Sav market, his mother shopped in." In section 2 you also say the Dragon flew from the Walmart parking lot. So, should it be Walmart or Sur-Sav.
Section 2: The story is hard to follow. It would help if the son had a different name.
Paragraph one: you used tired feet, twice, back to back. And you might add "his wife, Fran" to make clear who Fran is.
I like: "faint smile ghosted across his lips" and "anything to help him forget what happened to his little sister." In fact, I enjoyed your many unique phrases.
Section 2, paragraph 7 "her eyes opaque" does not make clear what the emotion is. Third sentence has an extra "she". I would leave out "then" and "too" at the end of the sentences. They aren't needed.
Paragraph 10 I think "never tire" sounds better than "get tired". I especially like: "heart too heavy to get off the ground" it backs up your flying simile. I also like "lucky nights of oblivion".
Paragraph 11 again the flight simile is very good.
Paragraph 12 "shell" is not clear enough.
Paragraph 13 consider leaving out "and drowsed" it would make the sentence stronger.
Paragraph 17 – 19 makes a really good connection to section 1
Section 3
The name George meaning a different George, is confusing. I had to reread twice.
I tried not to skim, because I am critiquing. Again you have too much irrelevant detail. My own rule is: if it does not move the story forward, or contribute to character, it is irrelevant detail. No matter how great the phrasing, it should be deleted.
Paragraph 8 on to the end is well done.
Your premise is interesting.
You might consider adding a connecting phrase at the beginning of section 2 and 3. Something like "30 years later", "as time marched on", or" the years flew by".
This is my first critique. I hope it is not too much.
Happy Writting
Patty
Printed from https://webx1.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/lightmasters/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
All Writing.Com images are copyrighted and may not be copied / modified in any way. All other brand names & trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
Generated in 0.07 seconds at 11:02pm on Aug 29, 2025 via server WEBX1.
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
