%%USERNAME%%    %%ACCWORDS%% %%ONOFF%% |
ASIN: B009B246X0 ID #115287 |
Multiply: Disciples Making Disciples (Rated: 13+)
Product Type: Kindle StoreReviewer: Jeff  Review Rated: 13+ | Amazon's Price: $ 9.47
|
|
Further Comments... | ||
This isn't a book in a traditional sense where it's meant to be read straight through and tells a story... it's actually teaching material that's meant to be supplemented with online videos. I'll admit that I haven't watched any of the videos yet, and I did read the book straight through (over several days) even though the authors recommended taking it in small chunks and really soaking it all in. I will probably revisit this book a few times over the years, but as a whole I wasn't terribly impressed. The book is broken down into five parts, each of which has subsections that each include context, with study/prayer questions at the end: I: Living as a Disciple Maker II: Living as the Church III: How to Study the Bible IV: Understanding the Old Testament V: Understanding the New Testament Parts IV and V were basically summaries of important stories in the Bible which, while interesting, aren't really new information... and this took up the majority of the book. Part I was basically "here's why you should listen to what we're saying in this book," which also isn't terribly engaging. And parts II and III, while interesting and informative, were written in kind of a presumptuous, condescending tone that really didn't sit well with me. For example, in Part III (How to Study the Bible), there's a subsection called "Studying the Right Book for the Wrong Reasons," and it outlined three of the key ways that people read the Bible incorrectly. Here's an excerpt, with the study/prayer question included: Guilt ... Very often, this guilt is connected with legalism. We create our own standard ("I must read X chapters per day") and then hold ourselves over to it, never stopping to consider that God has not placed this standard on us, we have placed it on ourselves. It doesn't take long before we begin holding other people to that standard as well. And thus a culture of guilt is formed, a culture where "good Christians" read their Bibles because they're afraid not to, and "bad Christians" feel guilty about not meeting their Bible reading quota. Status ... But take a minute to ask yourself why you want to know the Bible well. God is pleased when we treasure His Word, but do you really think He is pleased with your desire to appear intelligent? Does your desire to be the "go-to guy" who is never stumped really bring Him glory? What about your desire to be recognized as the best or most spiritual person in the room? Teaching Material ... The problem arises when we begin to approach the Bible as only a source for teaching material. If you are in a role where you preach or teach to others, do you find yourself simply scanning the Bible for nuggets to share? Or do you soak in the Scriptures because of what they have to say to you, listening to what God wants to teach you, allowing the Bible to transform you in unexpected ways? Take a minute to think about your past experience with reading studying the Bible. Which of the wrong motivations listed above are you guilty of? Can you think of any others? I think what grates on me about this style is the assumption the authors make about the reader's motivations. They offer a few incredibly specific scenarios for why they think people read the Bible for the wrong reasons, and then extrapolate that out and assume most of their readers are familiar with those reasons. And while I'm sure there are some people who do struggle with these very specific situations, I think there are a lot more like me who read it and don't really recognize the picture that's been painted. Which is not to say we all don't have our own wrong reasons for reading the Bible to some degree, but painting a very particular picture is likely to do the opposite of what they intend. Instead of someone saying, "You know, now that I think about it, maybe I do read the Bible out of guilt, or as a way of achieving status... I should examine that." There are probably a lot of readers who read it and go, "Well, I have a Bible reading quota but I don't hold other people to my standards so I'm not a "guilt" reader." Or, "Sure, I like that people think of me as a go-to person for Bible knowledge... but it's not because I want to feel intelligent or because I want to be the best or most spiritual person in the room... so what's so wrong with being knowledgeable about the Bible?" It creates opportunities for the reader to disassociate, because the authors have been so specific in their criticisms. Similarly, the question is asked in a way that's like, "Obviously you're guilty of at least one of these very specific wrong motivations. And what else?" When, in reality, they provided a few very nuanced examples rather than broad strokes or general categories for people to consider and apply as it fits their particular circumstances. I've really enjoyed Francis Chan's books in the past, but this one just didn't hit the mark for me. Perhaps it was a blended style with a co-author, or perhaps it was written during one of the periods of his life that Chan admits were times where his faith was misguided or not fully formed. Then again, maybe I'm bringing my own baggage to it and splitting hairs because the book it's catering to my particular desires and whims. I plan on keeping the book around and referring back to it from time to time, and maybe even watching the videos at some point, but it didn't feel like a book on how to disciple people well (what the book is purportedly about) as much as it is a handbook to exploring your own faith and blind spots. | ||
Interested in buying this? Support Writing.Com by making your purchase of Multiply: Disciples Making Disciples from Amazon.Com!
Created Mar 14, 2024 at 6:49pm •
Submit your own review...
| ||
un: 
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Community Feed
Puzzle Hub
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
