"Um, okay," Alex answered Jenna's question. He still seemed quite surprised by the whole thing.
"Good. Let's go." Jenna grabbed Alex by the arm and dragged him toward the bathroom before he could change his mind. Some of the girls giggled as the pair walked off.
"So, uh, why did you pick me?" Alex asked once they were in the bathroom.
"I don't want any of those jocks stretching out my clothes," Jenna explained. "But you're skinny enough that I shouldn't have that problem. I have to say, you're not the kind of guy I expected to see at a party like this."
"Oh, yeah, my friend Jeff dragged me here. His girlfriend is on the team," Alex explained.
"Jeff ... Jeff ..." Jenna muttered to herself as she tried to recall. "Oh, Megan's boyfriend?"
Alex nodded. "They ended up ditching me here too," he said, letting out a nervous laugh.
"Well I'll keep you company so I don't lose track of my clothes," Jenna teased. "After we swap you should come join the game."
"Alright," Alex agreed. "I guess we'd better swap then? So your friends don't think you're chickening out."
"Good point," Jenna laughed. "I like your shirt, by the way. Halo's pretty fun."
Alex looked down at his black t-shirt which featured a design Master Chief's helmet from Halo. "I didn't think a girl like you would like games," he said.
"Yeah I get that a lot," Jenna said. "But I have three older brothers. I grew up playing games with them."
"Oh, that's cool," Alex said.
"Anyway, let's do this thing."
Standing facing away from each other, the two removed their clothes and handed them off to each other. Jenna made sure Alex didn't steal any glances at her naked body, but he was well behaved unlike how she expected the meathead jocks at the party to have been in this situation.
Moments later, Jenna slid on Alex's boxers and jeans, then put on his shirt, his socks, and his sneakers. Alex, meanwhile, had managed to get on Jenna's panties and denim shorts, but he struggled with her bra.
"You've never been with a girl, have you?" Jenna laughed as she assisted him with the bra.
"Uh, no," Alex said, sounding somewhat dejected.
"Don't worry, I'm sure you'll find someone for you," Jenna assured him as he pulled her pink tank top over his head.
"I feel ridiculous," Alex said once he'd put on Jenna's shoes, which seemed to fit him just fine.
"My clothes look good on you," Jenna giggled. "Now, come on, let's get back to the game."
The pair made their way back to the game where they were greeted with laughs, though some of the guys seemed disappointed that Jenna was now wearing less revealing clothing. Thankfully for Alex, most everyone was too drunk to give him too much crap for wearing Jenna's clothes.
Once things settled down, Jenna took her spot on the couch and Alex sat down next to her, meaning it was now his turn. His dare ended up not being too horrible, only to take a shot of hot sauce. Jenna was impressed that Alex took it like a champ, downing the hot sauce like it was nothing, much to the disappointment of the jocks who would've liked to see a guy like him barf it up.